we miss leo k
Rejoint: févr. 2018
Messages: 6,014
Mentions "j'aime": 5,129
-I will keep banging this drum: Joel Edmundson missed 2/3 of last season with injuries. He's out for the first 1/3 of this season with a back injury (those always heal perfectly and never reoccur, right??) GMs are gonna want to see proof of life before giving up a bag of pucks for him, much less a package that includes a pair of young roster players and a 1st rounder. Comparing this to the Chiarot deal is insane - Chiarot got a 1st, a 4th, and a recent 3rd rounder when he was retained down to $1.75M. This is a 1st, a 4th, a 23 year old middle-6 roster player, and a top 4 D. No way.
-Give me more than 4 games of Monahan looking alive before you're flipping him out for a 1st. He started out at 0.5/ppg last season (7-12-19 in 37 GP) before falling off a cliff in the second half (1-3-4 in his last 28 GP). GMs will remember this, along with his recent injury history, and it's going to affect his value. I appreciate that you're at least including another asset with this for Colorado, so the value is closer to reality, but I still say that Monahan probably gets moved for a B-prospect and pick after the 1st round if he stays healthy and somewhat productive.
-A 3rd for Dad fully retained is fine, just make sure they're not on his NTC this time.
-Drouin needs to stick in the lineup before he gets any sort of return, but if he stays healthy and plays more than 3/4 of the game between now and the deadline, I could see a return along these lines.
-Not enough for Meier, I think. Gotta climb the prospect ladder - I can't see the Sharks moving him without getting one slam-dunk prospect that's NHL-ready (not Guhle, but whoever you'd rank right below him - Justin Barron? Filip Mesar?) Another team who wants Meier can easily beat this package, is what I'm saying.