Quoting: CantStopWontStop
I see 3 pretty attractive benefits to following the Habs 3 goalie strat:
1. Diversity is Strength. 3 same skill and aged dudes in different leagues, different coaches sharing what works and what doesn’t for multiple years.
2. If you want to target having a goaltender of a specific age in the future, this is likely the most reliable path. Anything else is more of a crapshoot.
3. By leaving a traditional pick distribution, this years draft can be sandwiched by drafts complimentary for other positions without worrying about goalies at all, unlocking opportunities for forward or defensive pairs to be drafted together.
I like it.
I’d try it.
I bet other teams will.
You’re gonna either crapshoot or crapshoot but weird.
Edit: glaring downside -
Fans won’t like it I guarantee it.
We have an abundance of promising LHD.
We just picked up another promising younger center before the draft and have a few looking to push for a spot soon.
We have several promising wingers in addition to any of those centers who may end up converting to wing.
We took the best RHD option available. Could use some more in the organization in general, but it's acquiring high end guys that is problematic.
There was simply no need to go after anything but RHD or G. Outside the first few rounds you're mostly looking at depth guys and role players, and those spots can be filled fairly easy when necessary.
Goaltending is the one area where we don't currently have a high end option. Our current tandem is a stop gap, Primeau hasn't inspired confidence, Dobes is promising but far from certain.
With the lack of certainty in net in the future, it doesn't hurt to have a few options to work with and see who can make it. We're used to having an "heir apparent" in the system, but have failed several times to turn the next "chosen one" into an NHL starter.
Perhaps this is the different approach we need.