What in tarnation
Rejoint: oct. 2017
Messages: 32,709
Mentions "j'aime": 31,449
Fans can only make "educated guesses" of what's going to happen, as they're no professionals. In the end everything we do here is subjective and based on opinions, and for a fan a player's value is their subjective feeling of how much should the asset get back based on their own evaluation, other background info like statistics and comparables of the past, as well as the consensus opinion given by other people. That's the whole point of fans discussing about trades.
My point is that if one posts a trade that the consensus opinion calls idiotic and unrealistic, then in this context it's probably just that. It doesn't mean it couldn't happen, but if it does there's not much sense behind it. And this is why there's almost never a trade of which the fans of both participants can consider fair.
If you don't want to hear your trade idea being "way off" or "unrealistic", you're probably in the wrong place, because when things are subjective there's always going to be opinions who think this way.