Rielly+Matthews for him only.

Apparently your wife. 😂 Not yours, to be clear. I forget what the insider said about the Ducks and how much they love Manson, but a wife was mentioned, haha.

For the current edition of Manson it'a be an overpay. You've paid Muzzin and Manson a total of 9.7m. Leafs would 10 times better off keeping Dermot at 2.7, and then have 7m to spend on other Dmen.

An asset that would be useful to the ducks

Its been stated like 100 times now. Any trade that has Anaheim sending Manson to Toronto has to have Liljegren going the other way. Anaheim doesnt need Jonsson's or Dermotts, they already have like 6 of them each

The line was "Your wife doesn't love you as much as the Ducks love Manson"

Exactly this, It's been stated numerous times that those pieces don't fill a need for the Ducks. And yet they keep proposing them. Thinking they will get a different result.

Josh Manson is overrated due to the ducks lack of any RHD, value wise it would be similar to the Muzzin acquisition, but due to Anaheim's inability to see reason and lack of RHD that's not possible

Typical leafs fan, overvaluing players. Rielly is a bottom pair D at best and Matthews is over paid. Add nylander and a 1st and retain 50% on all 3 and Ducks still say no.

Stated by who? CapFriendly users? That's a very reliable source

I havent seen any proposals that included a 1st round pick. Although to be fair there have been 11,000 manson trade proposals

Not even close. Start with Liljegren + 1st and keep adding

Lol that's probably because the Leafs don't have a 1st rnd pick that they can actually send until after the draft lottery or the seal a playoff spot. Has there been alot of AGMs trading for Manson other than Leaf AGMs?

You're just silly

Precisely why Josh Manson is severely overrated, nothing about Meat and Potatoes Josh Manson warrants that disgusting overpay, other than I want I want I want

You made the comparison to the muzzin trade not me.

Half this site is leafs fans. Most trades involving manson are leafs fans. Clean up your own backyard

No, you're silly...



No, we just don't have to move him unless we get what we need. We set the price. It's up to you if you want to pay it. For some unknown reason, TOR fans think that KK + Liljegren + 1st would get them an elite RHD. It wouldn't. If it did, TOR would have made that deal already.

Who said anything about elite? TO has no room cap wise for another elite D man, we can go back and forth all day, you are correct Anaheim has no need to move Manson just as TO has no need to overpay for a Meat and Potatoes D man when they could throw a B/C prospect and a 2/3 pick at Ottawa for Demelo who is the exact same player that Manson is.

I'd have 0 problem giving a 1st a B prospect and a fringe NHLer for Manson which is what was given to get Muzzin, I do have an issue and it is an overpay to pay a 1st plus Liljegren (he's an A prospect) plus plus plus

Demelo has never played top pairing minutes against the level of competition that Manson has, but fill your boots mate.

*facepalm*

Again, I havent seen those proposals. I have seen 450 Bracco, Ceci and Johansson ones though

Well that's preposterous

Lol Bracco I've seen those too lol

He's done it all season long this season, whether it's Manson or Demelo niether of them are game breakers or solve the defensive woes of TO that failure is a team effort