I would suspect you would need to give up the #4 pick. Yea Marner has his playoff woes but you're still getting a top 7 (?) RW in the entire NHL.

Marner should be able to draw a bigger return than just Jiricek, I'd expect a few picks along with him

no, because marner won't waive for columbus

Marner is a top 10 winger 100% but that is just way to much

Jiricek is not available. We can't afford to lose him.

No. Marner is overpaid and does nothing more than what we already have on the roster. Just not a match.

Thinking Marner even waives to CBJ is just pure delusion.
But the trade is so bad for CBJ. Wouldn't CBJ be so much better keeping 1m Jirikek and then spend 10m on UFAs rather than one year of Marner

If only there were fifteen other posts a day since game one of the Boston-Toronto series you could reference.

Because you asked nicely: there's a couple of pieces Columbus wouldn't trade under any circumstances for Marner, because of team/positional need and the fact that Marner (though great) is kind of redundant positionally with Gaudreau and fiscally irresponsible with Laine here. Fantilli, Werenski, Jiricek, 4OA, and Jenner are all off the table based on how important they are for the team. And frankly, we don't want/need Marner badly enough to part with any of them at this time.

If there's a Marner trade that could be worked out without involving any of those pieces, great, I'd suggest something like this: ACGM I did a couple days ago

If not...Toronto is better off sending him elsewhere, thanks but no thanks.

Well then swap out Jiricek for someone else. Jiricek is still developing, and I'm sure TOR would want someone a little more seasoned to help within their current window.