Modifié 15 oct. 2023 à 14 h 29
Quoting: RipNasty
It's so telling when you use numbers like these to support your argument but then also say stats aren't everything. Just watch McCabe. He's never in the right position in our own zone. He's got the worse plus minus on the team through 2 games and if you watch the replay on the goals he was on the ice for, he's just not covering his man. He gets lost often, takes weird routes to guys and is in fact not at all good at clearing the net. He gets his chances in the ozone but fires the puck at the goalies chest or misses the net entirely. I didn't like the trade and definitely don't like it now. Despite what most think, the right side isn't TO's weakness, it's the left side. Rielly is great. McCabe is not a top 4 defenceman on a contender and Gio just isn't good enough anymore. Moving Brodie to the left side of Klingberg, and shifting McCabe and Gio down and out would make the team better.
Klingberg definitely isn't as terrible as many said he'd be and will get better the longer he plays under Keefe. A net positive for sure, anything he gives up defensively he makes up for offensively.
The reason hes out of position is hes covering for 2 Dman lul. Klingberg's not good at defense leaving McCabe to do all the work. When he and Brodie were together along with Liligren they looked great together. We saw this years ago with Muzzin-Barrie. Muzzin's numbers dipped and he was often out of position covering for Barrie. Also needs to work on his Odd bad-timed pinches but those should be gone by Nov. As in the end hes a very underrated good defenseman
Pushing Klingberg down to be with Giordano and either moving Liligren up or Brodie down should help
And yes the right side is Toronto's weakness idk what else to tell you
Brodie looks like his playoff self (bad)
Liligren looks like he did after the TDL (bad)
And while Klingberg has done what we needed offensively he is not good defensively and if our 2 guys above who are supposed to be good defensively are struggling this makes things bad.
McCabe, Rielly, and Giordano at least have looked good but not great. Each with their own flaws. Gio especially has had good moments in front of his net and on the PK blocking shots and doing his thing. Only problem is playing the puck with Liligren. Going and getting another LD would be a mistake for this team as the weakness is the right side. A RD who is a good net front defender is a must. Someone who either can push Brodie to third pair LD or who will push Liligren into playing better to keep his spot