Quoting: jnowariak
I don’t think Greenway’s value is that high. Georgiev would be what the package is built around and I wouldn’t do it 1 for 1. I’m not sold on Kaapo yet, hopefully I get there next year but I can’t in good faith say he will be a tandem pairing.
I also don’t think NYR would part with the pieces we would be interested in, such as Strome or Chytil. I get the sense we will move Greener, but his value is still way up in the air.
I disagree, his value was most typically viewed as an early 2nd before the start of the season. Given his level of play and overall increase and improvement this year, even if it was inconsistent towards the end, I think it’s safe to say his value rose to at least a late-1st.
To put this in perspective, goalies aren't worth much in this league.
Jake Allen went to MTL for only a 3rd and a 5th.
Dubnyk went for a 5th in this year's upcoming draft and half retention to San Jose, and then for another 5th to the Aves.
Matt Murray was traded to Ottawa for a C-level prospect and a 2020 2nd.
Georgiev is definitely worth more than Doobs, but definitely not more than either Allen or Murray. There is no scenario where Georgiev is worth Greenway in a standalone strait up swap. None.