Imo Hart>Gibson, Bishop

Based on how many season(s)?

Finally someone acknowledges that Price is still a top goalie. Bishop on the other hand...

I’d lower bishop and raise hart. I’m glad that someone is giving Blackwood the respect he deserves.

2. The only metric which this is kinda flawed is with Bob. Hard to rate someone who was so good then went to crap. I wanted him in here, especially given the small sample size of Elvis, but just couldn't will it.

I'm not going to shut up about Korpisalo until it starts making sense 9 excellent playoff games do not make him a top 15 goalie he's not even a good backup

Hes a career .908 the only goalies with worse career sv% are the likes of Hutchinson, Cal Pickard, etc.

Tf is wrong with everyone here honestly

Lol no gibby>> Carter fart

Bishops only issue is health. He's an incredible goalie when healthy. Actually amazing stats. I have no clue why the fans are so hard on him.




Here to make friends, are you?

Korpisalo is one of the worst 15 goalies of the entire 2010s how on earth is he even considered for this

If 9 playoff games suffices to get him on this list

Fernando Pisani is a Hall of Famer

He's got good raw stats but that's only a product of Dallas's defense. @justaBoss knows quite a bit about how overrated Bishop is

wheres grubauer

im sorry which goalie made the playoffs?

I’m sorry which goalie was stuck on the worst team in the league and is routinely in hart conversations for being the only reason his team ever has a chance at playoffs?

Gibson been disrespected - him over bishop and tuuka

My guess: 1. Markstrom has been very average until last year - when his GP was reduced.

Love it. THE most overrated goalie.

He stole the series from the leafs. Can't deny the man

Or how about the fact that he had Columbus’s first 19 wins this season when Merzlinkins was sporting a sick 6+GAA and was bouncing between the AHL and the NHL.

Though I would say both Korpisalo and Merzlinkins are between 15-20 and neither should be top 20.

Bishop is way too high

Well I dunno about that. Dallas' playing system is somewhat defensive but on paper aside from Heiskanen Dallas isn't really a defense first team.

If Bishop were a little more durable and say 3-5 years younger I'd absolutely have him as a TOP5 G. Nowadays maybe TOP15 is sufficient...he hasn't been healthy since January, which was when his statistics started to drop massively.

Price, Korpisalo, Markstrom, Blackwood and Merzlikins are not top 15 goalies

It's a 2 year average list so I had to put him in for a sensational first year. This year health was the only and main issue.



Lemme guess, you want Jarry in the top 10. lol

ur right price is top 10, at the worst, only reason his team hasnt been a perennial lottery team