There ya go

https://www.capfriendly.com/armchair-gm/team/1697395

It's not enough, the price to acquire a player like Matthews is way too much. It doesn't make sense.

And only people who don’t know hockey think they can win the SC with Holl in the top4

He’s a 6th in STL, BOS, TB and COL, a 5th in CAR, WSH, PIT, PHI, VAN, CGY, EDM...

Nope, you just watch him walk as a UFA or you get killed on a max deal

Chicago too!

I don't think TOR should trade Matthews either.

I just don't think VGK would accept this.

Frankly, I think neither would accept this.

Fair value? Where?

- Matthews is a 22 year old top 3 shooter in the league and is a centreman than plays above average defence.

- Stone is 28, and while an elite defensive player in the league, with as physical of style that he plays he'll burn out by the time he's 32 or 33 and Toronto is still stuck with that awful contract.
- Karlsson is nothing more than an average 2nd line centre and was really a 1 year wonder where his shooting percentage was through the roof. Not to mention he's 27 and that's Toronto giving up 5 years of window time.
- Krebs is nothing more than a good prospect. They're magic beans. Might work out, might not. & if he does, it'll never be near the level of Matthews. & with Toronto trying to win now, it doesn't make much sense to take on a prospect.

It's really no question for Toronto to not even consider this offer. That's not even mentioning that you have the Leafs giving up the higher pick along with the youngest, and best player in the deal. Plus, Toronto takes on $15.4M in cap space (plus Krebs' contract if he played in the NHL) and they're adding $3.766M to their already tight cap situation and they don't even address any team needs in this idea. Honestly, it's not even worth any consideration from Toronto's perspective.

Yes, he is worth that. I'd do it, only if the picks are token out.

This deal might work out to be fairly even for the next 2-3 seasons.
But it will likely look terrible for Toronto for the 5 season after that.

THEE YEARS FROM NOW:

- Mark Stone will be in his 30's and signed for another 5 seasons at $9,500,000 (He's great right now but we don't know how long his prime will last)
- Will Karlsson will be in his 30's and signed for another 5 seasons at $6,000,000 (He's been trending down in GPG and PPG for for 2 seasons already)
- Peyton Krebs may or may not be an impact player at NHL level (he hasn't played a pro game yet so I won't make any predictions).

AT THE SAME TIME:

- Auston Matthews will be 25 and entering his prime with 2 years left on his contract (and could potentially be a top 2-3 player in the NHL).

It makes zero sense for Toronto unless Stone + Karlsson are a massive improvement on Matthews for the next 2-3 years (and they're not).