A lot of these players have passed their prime.
You can't call Hughes overrated when he is 18 years old
Larkin is underrated
Guentzal is underrated too
wouldnt call Reilly, Hughes, Larkon or Marray overrated dont think Kotkaniemi's overrated as well even Karlsson,,, everybody already thinks he sucks but give him time... his career in ott wast imaginary
Price is still elite he plays on a bad team it's not his fault
I guess it depends on your definition of overrated. Price had a GSAx of 38.88 in 2014-15, the season he largely built his reputation of best goalie in the world off of. The team was not good that year either, but he saved almost 39 more goals than an average goalie would have been expected to save.
Now compare that to the past three seasons of -11.04, 4.46, and -25.63 and hes probably been about almost 50 goals off of the season he had built his reputation off of on average. Keep in mind this is GSAx which takes into account the quality of shots he is facing. In 2017-18 Niemi put up a +14 GSAx in his time with MTL, compared to Price's -25, playing for the same team. There is no excuse for that, the stats clearly show Price was just plain awful that year.
Now with how big a reputation price has in the league and being the highest paid goalie, I think there is a strong arguement to be made that he is overrated, even if he is still a very good goalie.
what a great list I stopped at Jake Guentzel…. I thought to myself why waste anymore time reading this terrible list. yeah lets say a kid that signed a extremely team friendly deal and was on pace for 90 points and 42 goals is overrated. Guentzel is the type of player that every team needs.... hE iS a CrOsBy BaBy…. oh yeah what do you want him to do suck while playing with Crosby? like how does he get rid of this stupid narrative? omg hes only good when he plays with Crosby or malkin…… oh man well look at that the penguins have malkin and Crosby so I guess Jake Guentzel is going to be a bonified superstar till both decide to retire but lets diminish his accomplishments.... also hes a stud in the playoffs.... what at terrible take