Horrible trade for MTL

Horrible trade for STL

Just doesn't make senses for both teams.....

Terrible idea. You should trade ANY of your LhDs (including Mike Matheson) before trading Kaiden Guhle.

MTL just aren't trading Kaiden Guhle ...
People including Suzuki Caufield Slafkovsky Dach Guhle and Reinbacher in trades are just craving attention

They should trade ALL of the other LDs before trading Kaiden Guhle lmao.

Well - Don't get me wrong. I Like Gulhe, but I think his ceiling is limited to top 4... and he won't reach that Top D spot. Dickinson has better tools IMO.

Doesn't mean you have to trade Guhle at a loss, and well before Dickinson will be ready to fill his spot no less.
This would set the rebuild back significantly while not addressing the teams only real long term need, that being a true gamebreaking scoring forward

TBH - I doubt the scenario above happens - At least one of the mentionned forward will be available at 6th or 7th ovr.

The front office, the whole team and the fans seem to absolutely love Neighbors. He’s made an extremely ineffective power play very effective due to his willingness to pretty much do anything you tell him to.

I don’t see any world where him or Thomas are moved. I could see arguments for pretty much any other player on the roster, even though some wouldn’t make sense.

I really like Guhle, I also don’t really see MTL moving him, for the type of trade we’d probably look to acquire him for. Not to mention we would also then probably need to find a way to move a defenseman not named Parayko for a 2nd liner afterwards. Pretty much robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Not the worst idea ever, just highly unlikely either team would part with their guy.

Well - I want Neighbours for the same reasons you want to keep him!

but fair enough - Probably a lower deal for Jordan Harris could be done - less implication

I guess you haven’t noticed but he's already reached that top D spot. I feel some fans have turned on Guhle a bit lately but it’s completely unwarranted. Sure he makes some mistakes but the kid is only 22 playing top pairing on a rebuilding team. Imagine what he’ll look like at 25 when this team is ready to contend.

I was thinking of the exact same thing the other day, but a 1 for 1. Can't speak for STL, but MTL definitely will have a harder time replacing Guhle than finding a winger to complete the top 6.

Not sure what the reason is that everyone is horny to trade Guhle, and for losses at that, but it's insane and needs to be stopped. My word people.