Rejoint: sept. 2018
Messages: 2,096
Mentions "j'aime": 1,770
I mean, you have to take a top-5 player right now, generational goal-scorer, in his prime, with term. I love Fantilli so far, and I hope Matthews is his ceiling. But that means the right choice is to take Matthews if you have the option. Even a Bedard-Matthews 1-for-1 swap I'd take Matthews, just because it's a known quantity with an extremely high ceiling.
4-5 years from now, maybe the equation is a little different. It also matters that CBJ have players now (Laine, Z, Gaudreau, Severson, etc.) that should theoretically push them to compete. If you're looking at a franchise that's in the baby stages of a rebuild (like a Chicago), the answer could also be different.