Marner trade to Detroit starts with Seider.

I think Montreal would want more if they're retaining.

Seider > Marner

Why give up a 2nd for a #4 RHD

first of all you are comparing a defencemen and a forward and second of all Marner is one of the core four guys u really think the price wont be high lol

This is not good

Wow that's might be a bit over his head? If has this much trouble with NHL player value. There is no way he is going to be able to contemplate his own existence.

who adds?

Every Leafs fan this site has put in an ACGM for far less. Now I know a good portion of the Leafs fans suffer from chicken little syndrome you panic with almost no provaction but I wouldn't trade Seider for Marner straight up.

yeah i undertand Seider Detroit's number 1 defencemen of the future and u guys dont wanna part with him. leafs arent gonna part with Marner easily either.

You are right I was comparing the wrong guy but why would the Wings want a player almost every Toronto fan wants to get rid of as soon as his play slips?

This makes about as much sense as wing ding

In the minds of wings fans Seider has already won 5 straight Norris Trophies and Marner is only a 60 point winger.

I love how in the minds of people on here, a few Leaf fans means all leaf fans.

Why is nobody talking about the Chychrun trade? It’s abysmal for the Wings

Ik the last 2 seasons he put up 60 points but in a full 82 game season he is capable of putting up over 90 points which he did a couple of seasons ago.

Guess Im not the only one having problems today I said most not all.

Marner is an elite topline talent on the wing. That’s indisputable.

At the same time, organizationally, we have a lot of wingers. We don’t have a functional defense. Trading what is now and projects to continue to be our solid 1D, even for Marner, doesn’t make sense. It adds on a positional strength and subtracts from an area that is already week.

even without retention.

about a month ago ALMOST EVERY Leafs fan wanted Marner gone.

He's been on a 90+ point pace since Babs took him off the 4th line in his 2nd season.

You literally said "every leaf fan"

I agree with that and I do apologize I have no idea why I switched Seider and Hronek. I'd apologize for being an asshole but then I'd have to apologize every other post and I'm just not that enlightened yet.

Silly to retain on him at all. If he absolutely can't be moved at his full cap hit for positive value, he stays until he can. Up to him to raise his value, waive his clauses, or agree to termination if he seriously wants to move.

Go back and read it!