Quoting: A_Habs_fan
Well first one is easy, Montreal makes playoffs over Columbus in 2019, no sweep, Tampa wins cup
2nd one Duchene to Montreal ???, probably through trade though Columbus wasn’t going to move Duchene so FA would’ve been more likely
Duchene gets traded for a 2019 1st + ( 2019 MTL 1st was Caufield at 15 ) wouldn’t be at 15 then but could still be a Krebs or something )
I think you kinda misunderstood, Duchene to Montreal was never gonna happen. I think the thread is:
1 - Montreal makes playoffs, gets smacked by Tampa, Tampa steamrolls again for the first of 3 straight cups.
2 - Because Montreal made the playoffs, they don’t get Caufield at 15oa. I’m assuming this is being seen as a difference maker in the Habs vs. Leafs series, however the Leafs are chokers and the Habs would still have Price so the Leafs probably still don’t win, especially if the Perry/Tavares accident still happens.
3 - Duchene would have been traded to Columbus only for Columbus to miss the playoffs, and then he would still walk in free agency to Nashville. This would be a horrendous trade for Columbus in hindsight, trading for a rental and not even making the playoffs, almost as bad as Ottawa/Nashville giving up Girard+Byram+more to get Duchene to Ottawa in the first place.