I guess one thread arguing about this wasn't good enough for you.

Easily Wilson

I would argue neither would be good enough to construct your team around.

This is the correct response, both are support pieces. If they are your team’s best player your team probably sucks

popping in to remind everybody that since signing his contract nylander has more playoff wins than tom wilson

From scratch? Nylander , I do get the argument of leafs needing Wilson more as they have 3 other elite talents up front and could use a power forward who can seamlessly play in the top six. If I was say Seattle and had to pick one for my top forward it’d be Nylander

Tom Wilson and I will make an ACGM for you.

Sure,Wilson’s probably the better all around player,but Nylander’s younger,and still improving...

Nylander, he's younger and has a higher ceiling. Tom Wilson just plays playoff hockey

Do you have a chart of them?😂😂😂

My exact opinion, you can add Corey Perry after if you want playoffs hockey.

should build the team around mondo

pros:
-cool guy
-best poster
-funny

cons:
-i am unable to play hockey
-i haven't skated in like five years

double post

Cody Ceci has more playoff series wins than the Leafs over the course of his career 😜

neither of them are players you build a team around.
But Nylander, easily. Without question. If you're starting from scratch you always take skill first. You can always add guys like wilson through trades. Look at what tampa did with Goodrow and Coleman?

except wilson isnt a better all around player. he's not as good in either end of the ice and is a significantly worse transition player

and luke schenn has more cups than the sens do in franchise history, what of it?

Ya maybe.

Nylander lol

he is, i mean it's not to say wilson is a bad player. Nylander is just really good. But some people think smashing a guy from behind and giving him CTE while you get suspended is more important.

Where did he win the other 6?

Well,ya.

Sorry, I dont include cups from an entirely different franchise simply because the new senators couldnt come up with an original name

K...

You can find another Nylander fairly easily. You will not find another Tom Wilson. Likely ever again. Wilson has the whole package on and off the ice. I'm sure other NHL players would rather have Wilson on there team than Nylander.