Crosby
Phaneuf
Karlsson
Suter
Frost
Panarin
Makar
Brown
McDavid
Bracco
Bishop

Crosby
Gud
Hedman
Suter
Comtois
Tavares
Makar
Brown
McD
Bracco
Bishop

Couture or Crosby? Seriously?

Just Remember folks. Logan Couture has 65 Playoff points in 60 playoff games the last 4 years. 30 in 15-16
Crosby 58 in 64 Ik he has 2 Conns but it’s who’s been the better Playoff producer for Crosby vs Couture

Crosby
Guddy (not taking into account cap/contract)
Hedman
Suter
Comtois (rn, completely biased, pens and ducks fan...)
Panarin
Makar (I'm extremely low on Byram though)
Brown
Bolts (point>Stamkos though)
Bracco
Freddy (both are very good, but Gibson>> )

Crosby
Phaneuf
Karlsson
Suter
Frost
Panarin
Makar
Brown
Mcdavid
Bracco
Bishop

ya, it's crosby. there is no debate. no discussion. crosby.

Couture is the best non ovie playoff player in the league so this is tough

There is a lot more to winning a cup than points, and Crosby has won 3. How many has Couture won?

If I remember correct that year Couture had 30 pts, Crosby won the cup and conn smythe. Not even a debate lol.

Crosby
yikes Gudbranson
Hedman
Suter
Frost
Panarin
Makar
Filppula
McDavid
Verhaeghe
Bishop

Couture is clutch in the playoffs for sure but do you know who is also clutch? Crosby. And if you're comparing them in the last 4 years like you said, Crosby had back to back Conn Smyth's and then followed that up with 21 points in 12 games the year after. If you're looking at the whole career instead, Crosby has 186 points in 164 playoff games which is just bonkers considering how hard it is to score in the playoffs. But sure, pick Couture based on 7 extra points over a 4 year span.