SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

HockeyGawd

I Am Score
Membre depuis
6 févr. 2022
Équipe favorite
Oilers d'Edmonton
Messages dans les forums
57
Messages par jour
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GM31 janv. à 23 h 44
Sujet: The Clapback after Lindholm trade
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Mr_Gardoki</b></div><div>Realistically, Jake isn't going anywhere, but as far as Jake offers go, there's something to this one at least. I'm not sure how I feel about Broberg; he looks to be a bust territory, but I don't think we're far off here.

I think if you swapped out Broberg for a different prospect we're getting close.</div></div>

Broberg isn't a bust at all. He's not the 8th overall pick that he was made out to be for sure, but not a bust. The Oilers just haven't utilized him/given him the chance by playing him as a 7th D with only 8 mins every night. Currently cooking the AHL. There's still a top 4 D there, just not on the Oilers and he has much better upside than Hunter Brus-something which is who I compared to in the Lindholm trade because that trade kind of sets the market for players like Guentzel. If that isn't enough, I guess we'd have to throw in Bourgault over Savoie.
Forum: Armchair-GM30 janv. à 4 h 26
Sujet: Jiricek Jenner
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>CaseyFlyman</b></div><div>Oh my god we're back to the Jenner discussion too.

It's absolutely missing another 1st and high end prospect. Arguably it's missing a 1st and <em><strong>A</strong></em> high end prospect, on top of Bourgault.

Jenner = 1st, 2nd, A-level prospect. Anything less and we'll just keep our 2C captain on one of the best deals in the league, or at least find another team.
(You really think Colorado, a team exactly one 2C and a backup goalie from the closest thing we've seen to hockey perfection in a while, wouldn't absolutely launch a 1st, 2nd, and Ritchie out the door for 3 cracks at a Cup with Jenner at $3.75M, especially if it means a team like Edmonton doesn't get him?).

Jiricek = Top-5 pick or U23 1RD. Anything less and we'll just keep our guy who will absolutely be 1RD before he's 23.
(You really think Toronto, a team with a dire need for cheap RD, wouldn't absolutely launch a 1st, 2nd, Cowan, +++ out the door to have Jiricek on his ELC for 3 years, and likely forever after that?).

Lets get real here. We've got enough middling prospects and filler players. We need quality, and we have that in Jenner and Jiricek. If you're getting <em>both</em>, you're sending us Draisaitl.</div></div>

Jenner for a 1st, 2nd and an A level prospect? Bro, Chicago got less for 40 goal scorer DeBrincat from Ottawa and that's nearly what Eichel's return was lmao. That's a crazy thing to say. He's defintely only worth a 1st, maybe a 2nd (probably a 3rd), and a B level prospect. This is Boone Jenner, not Mark Schiefele.

But you're right about Jiricek's value, yeah. I also never said he's going go to Edmonton for that value, but I thought you were implying that he fetches a 1st and a high end prospect when Jiricek is only a high end prospect, not a generational one. So if a high end prospect is in play, all you're going to get is a 1 for 1 or maybe a sweetner along with the high end prospect for Jiricek. Why would anyone need to give up more than that. It's a high end prospect for a high end prospect.
Forum: Armchair-GM29 janv. à 22 h 21
Sujet: Holland TDL Moves
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>CD282</b></div><div>Sure it was. He has a history of paying 1st+ for good players with term, irrespective of their age. That was a classic Holland move.

However, he has NEVER traded a 1st for a rental. Ever.

And he's had Ceci play 1st pairing for 3 years now, and when he's making just $3.25M you don't give that away for a 3rd.

And while he may go for Duclair, he won't add Janmark to the offer. Janmark is playing very good defensive hockey and has a key role on the PK.</div></div>

Good point on him never trading a 1st for a rental but they could always be signed. Tanev is a nice asset and aging so he's not going to ask for a raise.

Ceci is a 2nd pairing D. Ekholm-Bouchard pairing has been the 1st pair ever since Ekholm came. If he can get more for Ceci, ****ing great. But it's mostly just to get rid of the 3M because in his words, its "dollar in, dollar out"