Zero chance the Hawks take 2 years of 6.25 for quickly approaching 36 year old Petry for a 2nd (which is the net value of those picks for the Hawks). Further compounded by the fact that the Hawks have Jones, Murphy, and Zaitsev under contract as pricy RHD.

#14 OA in this class is worth more than I think you think it is.

That said, I agree that it's not 14 + Petry for 35 and 44. Probably more likely 44 + 55.

While I agree with a lot of what wojohawk and ChiHawk have said, I think if the Hawks have an opportunity to get #14 without giving up #19, that's something that gets explored. Assuming Petry waives (not a sure thing), yes, he's old. Yes, he's overpaid for what he provides on the ice. But he's far from a cap dump. He ain't Zaitsev or Peterson. He's a far more effective player than either of those two are. The only guy's he's "blocking" in Chicago are Mitchell (who the Hawks may not even bring back) and Regula ( who still isn't ready for full time NHL duty anyway). I'll take Petry on 3rd pair over Zaitsev or Caleb all day long. The quality of player the Hawks would get at #14 over what they'd get at even #35 makes this a deal the Hawks want to make in my eyes. Cap space is obviously no issue. Ok, maybe #35 and #44 is a little rich, but not so rich I just dismiss the idea of this trade. I'd trade #35 and #51 for sure to get #14 and take Petry. He's not a cap dump just because he's overpaid.

It makes a lot more sense if Murphy is traded IMO