There's no real point to the Flames trade from a Calgary perspective. If they could move Monahan easily then maybe Kerfoot comes in as a 3C and Pelletier filles Dube's spot but outside of a perfect fit I don't think Calgary does that, giving up an underperforming controllable asset for 1 year of an overperforming Kerfoot isn't great asset management.

Wow this is tough. I love Nylander, think he'd be a great fit in Jersey with Hughes but Siegenthaler is the best shutdown defenceman we've had in a loooong time. D core would need a ton of work if we lost him and Severson.

I think I'd still do it but I had to think about it for a while. Interesting proposal!

Could send back a guy like Kokonen, who’s a 20 yr old Left shot D man who’s one of the leafs top 5 prospects, he’s more so of a two way D man, but could still be a potential top 4 guy in 2-3 years tops

That’s why I sent it as a 1 for 1, with that exact scenario happening, Monohan leave in offseason, dune becomes expendable for someone who can be an upgrade to a 2/3C guy and Pelletier take over as well either as a winger or Centerman, also given they picked up Toffoli I thought maybe a play making guy for the 2/3C spot would help give the team 2-3 lines of scoring, leafs then take the cheaper guy who still has potential but is high risk, high reward

Well thought out for sure, I don't know if Calgary would bite but certainly an interesting thought!

Edmonton trades a young good winger for a broken down back up. I don’t see that as an option

Trevor Moore is playing top-6 minutes now, Muzzin is on the decline and riddled with injuries. Not sure our teams wants/needs are matching up any longer.

Sorry, we're not trading our newly-found #2LW for a Jake Muzzin re-run. We wouldn't even do that if the draft pick involved were Toronto's 2022 second instead of Pittsburgh's 2023 third. Top-6 wingers are hard to find.

Nylander is a good player, but we are not trading our best two defensemen for any winger.

Devils decline without reservation.

Caps say no. They don’t need those pieces.

Very good proposal. I’m like 50/50 in it but I think Devils say no because losing 2 dmen that are impactful like Severson and Siegenthaler would be a huge loss