Idk how anyone can watch the isles and think they need Ben Chiarot

Isles are looking for a PMer so send Kulak there for a 4th. Send Chiarot to Edmonton since they are looking for a stabilizing D man to play top 4 for a 1st. IF you really want you can sway Byron for Richie but Richie is useless and Byron is a great PK specialist.

dont they have five dmen hurt

why do the leafs do this? they dont need any more 4th liners, especially ones who are more expensive, longer term and older than Ritchie

well they should probably get a defender who is good then, not Chariot

Cap dump for cap dump with higher cap hit seems like a really bad move for a team with no cap space.

Yeah so giving up a *currently* top 10 pick for an OK defenseman is not a good move when half the team has covid and is currently below .500 in the toughest division in hockey.

chariot isnt even ok, he's straight up bad.

Sure, and they also have a top 10 pick right now. Ben Chiarot definitely isn't gping to change that

Chabot is worth a third round pick

Don’t you think that’s more of a reason not to give a 1st for a mediocre defenseman. Is Chiarot supposed to come in a and stabilize their blue line?

Chiarot is a glorified bottom pair dman, only ken holland and jim benning would pay more then a 3rd for him. isles are better off getting ghost or lindholm