Maybe it’s a good thing the best you could come up with for the Canes was Gardiner. He shouldn’t even be eligible for a list like this because who is ‘rating’ Gardiner anymore?
I don't think Keith was an overrated player a few years ago, but his game has declined and he isn't a top pair defensemen like some people say he is, so I'd agree
Bennett is overrated? All I hear about him is how he is so bad even though so far he has 3 goals and 5 points in 4 games...
All I ever hear when ever the flames played the oilers and when the flames played anyone else was "Oh look at Bennet, such skill, he's a really good top 6 winger."
Andersen isnt a bad pick, but there are a LOT of overrated leafs. Morgan RIelly should be considered
I wasn't sure which leaf to pick, either I pick Rielly and a bunch of leafs homers come an flame me or I pick anderson the at one time " Best goalie in the league!" or I pick one of: Tavares,Simmonds, Hyman, Brodie. I'd maybe say Matthews but it's leaf fans and media that overrate him so Ig it doesn't count.
Maybe it’s a good thing the best you could come up with for the Canes was Gardiner. He shouldn’t even be eligible for a list like this because who is ‘rating’ Gardiner anymore?
I don't watch many Carolina games and videos, I just hear Gardiner more than most I wasn't really sure who to pick there.
Kadri, Hischier and Pavelski are all underrated if anything...
Kadri is Massively overrated, All he does is cheap shot and annoy the other team, He's a Tkachuk that's actually good, Hischier has done nothing worth of becoming a captain and for some reason everyone thinks he's great, To be honest I really didn't know who to pick for Dallas, I picked Pavelski because he has 8 goals or something like that and everyone gets high on him.
Thats fine, hes still an elite 2way player in the making, just has to shoot more
I personally only picked him bc he gets talked about being really good right now which he's not. In the future he probably will live up to some hype and will be a good player he's just overrated for now.