I would be ok with both these trades if you drop Struble as Manson is not worth the first let alone a 1sr + good prospect

I think the majority of us, as Ducks fans, would typically agree, but the reported ask is a 1st+prospect. I think the ask is high because there's no real rush to move Manson, as he serves as a good buffer to ease Drysdale in.

apparently Bergevin is in talks for Gudbranson but nothing set yet

The Hoff trade could totally happen if you keep all your trash and just give the pick. Kulak and Stapley are of zero interest to the Blues. And sending Byron over would cost you a **** load if we could afford him, which we definitely cannot.

Which is why there should be no trades here. MTL should not be trading there 1st either unless they are adding a good long term piece, this team has shown no reason to add for a run at the cup, they could be picking 17th to 19th.

If it wasn't for them being in a 7 team division they likely wouldn't even be in a playoff spot and would be selling.

I agree. If I were Montreal, I wouldn't be going hog wild at this point. Offseason is a better time for them to be making moves.