Rangers probably.

Rangers easily. Call Howden and Gambrell a wash, Hertl is the better player. Gotta add to get him if the Sharks have even the slightest bit in moving him and or taking on Strome

Seems pretty lateral , why move Strome & take on more Cap for the same term? For Gambrel? Teams playing well & so is Strome , unless your getting an asset with maybe less production now but a higher or equal ceiling, younger but with more team control and/or term, its pointless.
Hertl is better in the dots but is he a piece after next season?
NYR likely wont protect Howden & would be hard pressed to protect Gambrell & risking losing say Guathier...

And i definitely don't know why SJ makes that deal?

Pass.

Rangers have to add

No way for San Jose.

Rangers add a lot imo. Strome is good in his role, but is a product of how incredible Artemi Panarin is. If you trade for Ryan Strome, you're not gonna get New York Ryan Strome. He's not nearly as valuable as Hertl, and there's no value here to make up for it. Brett Howden isn't worth anything. He's terrible

Get out of 2019

If he's so wonderful, why don't Rags fans want to keep him?

If he can be used as an asset in a trade improving our team, that's a different story. It's not like we want him off the team for whatever we can get...
After Zibanejad, Fox, and Panarin, Ryan Strome has been our best player for us this past week and a half.

Neither side would ever come to an agreement.

Rangers add in terns if overall value but I feel neither side would ever like this deal

Rangers add a lot.

Something called the cap. We only have 2 eventual tradables with cap; Strome & Buch.