Hedman not at #1 and having Dougie there is brutal. Rielly shouldn't be on this list and Im a leafs fan

Rielly's been amazing so far

This list sucks

Rielly and Carlson shouldn't make the cut, but other than that, not too many problems.

What would you change?

Is he the 9th best dman in the NHL though?

Hedman a bit high, I wouldn't have Carlson on here, but you'd get murdered if you didn't, very reasonable tho, Reilly to high as well

morgan rielly is the current mcdavid of dman, he is so good offensively that it doesnt matter how good defensively he is that much, he has been at the top in xWAR throughout the past few yrs

stfu you have draisaitl over crosby, you have no say lmfao

Is this sarcasm? I really hope it is

I’d have Seth jones up there.

Don't know how that's relevant, but I'd rather have Draisaitl right now. Crosby is 33 and injury prone.



Seth Jones might be the best defensive defenseman in the league right now.

Injury prone? This was his first year missing significant time since 2013. He’d not injury prone. Sid all day every day over Drai

Depends building a team of course age is a factor Big tipping point but which would want on team for one year it’s Crosby no question. I’m as big of a leon fan as anyone on here Crosby is the better player today no doubt.

https://www.nhl.com/news/nhl-current-players-ranked-top-centers-nos-10-1/c-317525840

NHL staff writer literally has them ranked Crosby 4, Drai 3 and I don't think that's wrong. It sounds like you're a biased fan.

How is Hedman high when hes literally the best dman in the league?

Nhl.com writers are known for their accuracy right? Drai isn't even a top 5 centre get out of here calling someone biased

Now you're the one that's high.

As a Leafs fan Rielly is not a top 10 Dman, Jones is top 3, McAvoy is not there, Weber should be there

Using NHL.com site to help your argument makes you sound like a fool. Their lists are always garbage. Ask players around the league and it’s clear cut Crosby and McDavid in another tier

you'll never get brownie points on capfriendly without having slavin and parakyo in a top 10 d list

Slavin, maybe. Soon at least.
Parayko is not top 10.

Leon was part of 2 different lines both ranked in the top 10 on 5v5 goal production this season, one with McDavid and one without (which had a 77.8 GF%). He was also a force on the PP with 44 points.

Crosby is a 1st ballot HOF'er and there's no question. I'm just not convinced he's as good as he was when he was the best player in the league. If he's sliding then other players are going to pass him. I think Draisaitl has. We'll see what next season looks like.

Sid, McDavid, MacKinnon, Matthews, Eichel and Pettersson are all better, more complete centres. Drai is the 2nd best offensive C behind McDavid but you don't have two top 5 Cs and lose to the Hawks

Funny stuff. It's literally in his job title.