Toews is on my list

Karlsson isn't overrated lol, he gets so much hate already. I agree with Duchene tho.

toews yes to list but MAF, Karlsson, Schimdt should not be on list.

I don't know if Zaitsev is really overrated, he's considered a solid player, that seems pretty fair.

I don't think he's overrated he's just over payed. He's a fantastic 2 way player who wins a lot of faceoffs and consistently puts up 50 points a year. Points aren't everything

Love the list but dont see how bobby ryan is on there, No one thinks he is good. He would definitely make the overpaid list but not overrated. He is rated accurately as a glass handed bottom 6 forward

I think zaitsev doesn’t deserve to be on here pretty much everyone thinks he’s the worst Dman in the league. Underrated if you ask me.

Ngl Bobby Ryan isn’t overrated. He is just terrible and on a terrible contract

You mentioned McDonagh. Just wonder well his new 6.75m, 7 year contract is going to play out over the years.

Rask? The guy is hated by his own fanbase (for the most part) and many people don't even consider him a top 10 goalie in the NHL lol.

What makes Pacioretty overrated? Just curious

I'm a habs fan and I can say that the 30 goals mean nothing when he scores 1 in the playoffs. He's a floater and a perimeter player. He never stood up for his teammates and never used his size to his advantage. That's just my opinion tho

He's the most overrated player in the NHL. Offensively he's better than some of the forwards in the league but defensively he's a total wreck. How can you have 82 points in a season and still be a minus but yet Byfuglien had 50 something points on a terrible non playoff team with the most ice time in the league and he was still a plus. I'm not saying he's a bad player he's just not as good as everyone thinks he is. He's far from being the best defenseman in the NHL.

I put him there cause all the leafs fans think he's gonna be a stud. Then again... it is leafs fans.

Well he is playing great this year so far he just needs to be good not great.

Dude just got paid because he won 3 cups in his first 8 seasons in the league, and he was almost a point per game in the playoffs. He had 2 down years but he looks to be back.

Bobby Ryan is underrated if anything. Same with Duchene.
Karlsson deserves every bit of hype he has.
Fleury was oustanding last season and has been for years.
I don't think McDonagh belongs on this list. Yes he had a poor playoffs but the guy is still a very good defenseman.