SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

HeadHighSauce

Dougie HIMilton
Membre depuis
17 sept. 2020
Équipe favorite
Devils du New Jersey
Messages dans les forums
3071
Messages par jour
2.3
Forum: Armchair-GM26 janv. à 20 h 34
Sujet: Boston fans
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Celtics21</b></div><div>Most indications are they are discussing an extension. Hes the one guy who Friedman keeps on mentioning as a likely extension candidate. When his agent went on their podcast, it didn’t sound like there was an issue. I’m expecting an extension before next season</div></div>

Could also be damage control. He said what he said, but when he said it (right after January 1st) is reason it’s worth talking about. Friedman said extension was likely on first day…but that day came and went.

And given the history of how these things rarely work out…despite fanbases believing otherwise…combined with higher likelihood of goalies getting traded in RFA year…it doesn’t look good from outside. But you all would know better than I would how Bs are handling.
Forum: Armchair-GM10 oct. 2023 à 14 h 42
Sujet: Pettersson
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>NHLfan10506</b></div><div>LOL.

We should trade him for RYAN REAVES! Because his career 0.07 pts/gm in playoffs is proof... size trumps skill!

MARCHESSAULT was awful last year.... Zero fights.

Get IVAN BARBASHEV! He HITS. Boom! His 0.18 ppg in playoffs is plenty.

JAKE GUENTZEL...good thing Pens benched him in their cup runs.

They could have won with a heavy winger like WILLIAM CARRIER! 0.11 ppg in playoffs, who cares? He is 220 lbs of man!

BRAD MARCHAND, take a seat.

If you fall behind, a guy like MATT MARTIN (0.15 ppg) can rip a guys face off. Because when you're down, you don't want goals. You want revenge!

CALE MAKAR is only good for regular season. Give me HAKANPAA!!!

KUCHEROV should be benched in playoffs. His buddy BRAYDEN POINT too. Who cares about their 1.13 and 1.02 ppg...they are lilliputians.

Lightning would have won something if they had MANTHA and LUCIC instead

FIALA, FOX, ZUCCARELLO....pass. PANARIN, no thanks.

KURTIS MACDERMID, PAT MAROON, JOEL ARMIA....start, start, start!

DEBRINCAT, GAUDREAU, MARNER....bench, bench, bench!

JOSH ANDERSON is elite!</div></div>

Tbf Ryan Reaves had a better P/60 at 5v5 than dach and Matt Martin scored the same amount of 5v5 points.
Forum: Armchair-GM10 oct. 2023 à 14 h 37
Sujet: Pettersson
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Savage27</b></div><div>Bratt was literally ineffective in the playoffs cuz he is undersized. 32 of 32 front offices would say size is not overrated</div></div>

LOL.

We should trade him for RYAN REAVES! Because his career 0.07 pts/gm in playoffs is proof... size trumps skill!

MARCHESSAULT was awful last year.... Zero fights.

Get IVAN BARBASHEV! He HITS. Boom! His 0.18 ppg in playoffs is plenty.

JAKE GUENTZEL...good thing Pens benched him in their cup runs.

They could have won with a heavy winger like WILLIAM CARRIER! 0.11 ppg in playoffs, who cares? He is 220 lbs of man!

BRAD MARCHAND, take a seat.

If you fall behind, a guy like MATT MARTIN (0.15 ppg) can rip a guys face off. Because when you're down, you don't want goals. You want revenge!

CALE MAKAR is only good for regular season. Give me HAKANPAA!!!

KUCHEROV should be benched in playoffs. His buddy BRAYDEN POINT too. Who cares about their 1.13 and 1.02 ppg...they are lilliputians.

Lightning would have won something if they had MANTHA and LUCIC instead

FIALA, FOX, ZUCCARELLO....pass. PANARIN, no thanks.

KURTIS MACDERMID, PAT MAROON, JOEL ARMIA....start, start, start!

DEBRINCAT, GAUDREAU, MARNER....bench, bench, bench!

JOSH ANDERSON is elite!
Forum: Armchair-GM9 oct. 2023 à 22 h 0
Forum: Armchair-GM31 juill. 2023 à 14 h 3
Sujet: Jack Hughes vs Elias Pettersson a debate
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>HeadHighSauce</b></div><div>&gt; If it's production, does that mean the 4% EV OFF Hughes has on Pettersson is more significant than the 6% EV DEF that Pettersson has on Hughes

It almost certainly is. per EH, the 100th percentile for EVD is 9.1 GAR. For EVO it's 25.6. Offense is much more valuable than defense (which, duh. you can't win if you don't score goals) in these models.

FWIW EH has Hughes at a total 22/23 WAR of 3.6 and Petterson at 4.4 with the biggest difference being defense and penalties. xWAR is 3.7 to 3.7.

different models will value different things differently though.</div></div>

Certainly as far as individuals go, offense is generally speaking than defense, but yeah I was talking more about the models which as you said do reflect that but there is the question of which metrics are being valued more over others in each model (as you mentioned).

The models do have a larger emphasis on 5v5 offense which is a good standard for comparing players, to try and isolate the players from the situational impacts. With these two who had the same overall production essentially, the way I see it (until there's more data to separate them) they essentially got to the same place while excelling at different things.