Necas isnt worth Beniers, maybe not Wright either

Oh really? Could Beniers work for you if you're trading Necas? That would be acceptable for you?

How’d you magically LTIR Freddy?

This isn’t a 1for1 is it? I like Goyette, but I wouldn’t trade Necas for him. If I was Carolina, I would much rather trade him for a RHD.

Benries is still a work in progress in my eyes and only has one season of top-6 production

It's Freddie... I'm sure you can find a way to stick him on LTIR

Yeah, that’s not really how it works.

And you are basing that on one season of production

The Leafs were able to find an injury serious enough to stick Matt Murry on LTIR and with Freddie's injury history I'm sure there is something still lingering

Just trade him for FC if you want him gone. The argument you’re making is non-sensical.

The Hurricanes don't really need a RHD... we have Morrow and Burns for next year and Chatfield could probably be resigned cheaply... so 2C is the real area of concern and I'd much rather go for a prospect long-term than somebody like Lindholm

Fair enough... it's basically the same thing

As opposed to Necas who has a long track record of what? 40-50 point play?

Potential (and position) matters. Two-way play matters. Seattle isn't sending you Beniers for Necas, not even close.

I mean the Kraken is also about to have a massive logjam at center... with McCann, Berniers, and Wright are all going to need Top-6 spaces and I'm sure we can add more but I think that deal could work for both sides

McCann isn't a center lol, and even if they did have that logjam, Beniers is the last one to go



That deal doesn't work for Seattle at all

So if Beniers is off the board what's your objection to Goyette going to Carolina?

I don't have an objection to Goyette, all I've told you is you're not getting Beniers for Necas

Surely you must realize how preposterous asking for Wright or beniers for necas is

Surely you can't be serious by mentioning Beniers and Wright

Tbh... I'd rather Wright or Goyette... More time for Rod to mold them

Wright was a little bit of a stretch but have you guys looked at Beniers production in the show? Like, come on... Necas is an established guy in the show and Berniers had one season of top-6 production and suddenly everybody is acting like he's untouchable and that's not even getting to linemates

My God. He's played 2 seasons.

Necas has 1 season in his whole career better than beniers age 19 season

At beniers age necas had 38 career points

Not a single chance Necas is worth one of Wright or Beniers lmao

The fact that he's only played two seasons is kind of my point... We still don't know whether year 1 or year 2 is the version of him that we're gonna get consistently.

I mean A. It doesn't hurt to ask and B. This was more about the upcoming logjam in the top-6 for Seattle... I can see four guys need two spots in the next two years