Quoting: TwistyShark1
How is the Arizona one bad.
To sum it up quickly:
1) You're asking for two pieces that Arizona has no interest in moving
2) You're asking for 4.3M in retention for 3-4 years on those two pieces, which costs a lot itself
3) The value you're offering is so far off what Arizona would get for those two pieces if they were to move them without retention, let alone with that much retention
Bertuzzi has virtually no value here as a pending UFA that walks at the end of the season, Arizona doesn't want or need him
Gregor is a typical 4th liner, again little to no value, Arizona has plenty of these
Hirvonen is a pretty mediocre prospect, dime a dozen guy that again Arizona has, or will have, in spades, given their rebuild, he doesn't move the needle
A late 1st? Fine, but Keller and Crouse both return a 1st+ each if traded, so that can't be your only piece of true value in the return for both, with 4.3M in retention