The 1st + 3rd covers the Campbell dump, but you're going to need to add a decent prospect to cover Blackwood. Maybe give Montreal someone else and give Bourgault to SJ instead.

Columbus declines. If Jenner did become available (which is highly unlikely), someone will pay more than that for him without retention.

Easy yes from the Habs IMO.

What do you think the Habs need to add to get Holloway instead of as well?

More than 3x1st for an injured 4h liner on a bad team....wooow

Get your facts straight before being condescending

I think all of Montreal, San Jose and Columbus decline, though I think the issue is more fit/situation than value.

-I don't really see Montreal using their last retention spot for this season for another veteran D-man and Bourgault. Ceci has very little to no value to Montreal. Bourgault is a good prospect (I actually like him more than any other Oilers prospect), but it seems like if he sticks in the NHL it will be as a two-way middle/bottom-sixer and I'm not sure that's what Montreal would be looking for if they to use that last retention spot.
-Its probably going to cost more to both move Campbell's contract and acquire a goaltender from San Jose. The term on Campbell's contract is killer
-I think Jenner gets overrated, but he's a big center who can score on a sub-4 mil contract with term. That always has value and it will likely cost more or require different prospects to convince Columbus to move him and retain on his contract.



Jenner literally leads Columbus forwards in TOI/game. I don't think its realistic to think a 30 year old Jenner gets a (future) 1st and two recent 1st without retention, but the issue may be more on availability and/or the prospects fit/value than anything else.

Monte

Campbell will be bought out in the offseason.

Not saying it wont happen, but the buzz in market is that they would prefer to trade him and have no dead cap money on the books which is obvious, but all the insiders are saying the same thing so would assume they just pay up to rid themselves, or hope a team like sharks needs money on books to reach cap floor for next few years of tear down

He isn't an NHL goalie anymore and with 3 x $5M left on his contract the price to move him will be expensive to get another team to take him.

Capfriendly is a beautifull place where you can be told the same day that Monahan (18:30 TOI, 22pts) is a 3C worth a 3rd round draft pick and Jenner (19:15 TOI, 19 pts) is a 1C worth 3x1st.

I was wrong calling him a 4C, but it doesn't make this evaluation less ridiculous.

I guess it depends who actually said what, as none of us speak for the site, but IMO:

-Monahan is definitely worth more 3rd round pick (and wasn't mentioned in this thread)
-Jenner is likely not worth 3 1sts in a vacuum
-Broberg and Holloway may not be worth the same as a late 1st to Columbus or other teams
-Monahan and Jenner don't compare as one is a rental and the other has term, and play different games
-Both of them shouldn't be playing center on the top 2 lines of contenders (which is why this thread has Jenner as 3C in Edmonton)