Quoting: Victor24
Every single trade is undervalued on the Pens side.
Quoting: AStovetop
Colorado probably isn't the team to get Guentz, but I think he gets more than that. Carolina would make more sense
Oilers should absolutely do that IMO
No chance Arizona does that, even if they do have an endless supply of 2nd rounders
Quoting: pens1991
These are terrible deals for the penguins?????
I think Jake to COL makes sense, but I doubt that's where COL adds. Jake is worth a 1st + prospect (or 2nd) at deadline.
POJ is not worth a 3rd.
Pety and Smith NTC's block the trade to Arizona. Pety retained at 50% is easily returning a 1st to a team contending that needs a defenseman badly (TOR/DAL/NJ/Etc). Not sure what you can do with smith given his cap hit and realistically the pens would retain on Jake and Pety and those spots are the only two open.
The EDM trade is god awful. How do you not have a pens getting a 1st round pick in that? No one is taking Campbell's cap/term without at least a 1st coming back and EDM knows that.
if we were doing a full rebuild, which we're simply not... worst case is a retool... bc that's the mandate from ownership I believe until I hear otherwise.......
then putting that aside......
gotta think PIT could get a 1st back from EDM esp with taking the Campbell deal... and broberg requested a trade, so his value is down... and they have been super desperate for goaltending...
that would be steal for ARI, but I see them building from within and not making splashes at the TDL even if they're in the mix...
Guentzel does have more value if we retain, but don't think COL would be the team to get him... I have previously thought of LAK, MIN, FLA, SEA but who knows honestly at this point....