I’d have Leon clear number 2 both years

Is this based on where they stand today? Over their career? Potential production? Overall success?

Hertl over Barzal easily.

Miller is a lot better than a few of those guys

Tavares should be here

Eichel and Zibanejad are far too low on this list, both should be above Aho.
Barzal is playing strictly on the wing now
Stutzle and Thompson are all offense, no defense. They should be rated similar to Scheifele, Miller, or Malkin (Malkin should at least still be top 20)
Lindholm, Malkin, Miller, Thomas > Larkin. Probably Tavares too

eric haula?

Crosby over Point
Where is Malkin?
Zibenejad, Larkin and Stamkos (why is he not on the list) are better than Nico
Where is JT?

Funny joke!

Today

Are you sure? Miller can't really play defense and i would want a forward who can defend

These comments are brutal. Here is my list:

2021: McDavid
MacKinnon
Matthews
Draisatl
Barkov
Point
Aho
Crosby
Eichel
Hughes
O'Reilly
Pettersson
Barzal
Bergeron
Malkin
Backstrom
Giroux
Kadri
Couture
Seguin


2023:
McDavid
Matthews
Draisatl
MacKinnon
Hughes
Pettersson
Crosby
Point
Thompson
Eichel
Barkov
Laine
Kopitar
Aho
Hischier
Suzuki
Nelson
Thomas
Hintz
Beniers


Ignore the comments these are all subjective and people getting mad at you is so dumb. Sports is for fun and these rankings are literally impossible to get objectively correct

Our lists are so close and I could look at yours and thinks its mine. I had Barzal as a winger tho but like besides Suzuki, we are very close on everyone and all the guys you have who i dont are like 21-27 for me

Idk how you don’t have draisaitl at number 2 lmao his 55G 55A in 2021-2022 is more impressive than 60 goals only 3 players have done it since 1995 Lemieux and McDavid who did last year also didn’t draisaitl also have 128pts last year lmao for a guy that actually performs in the playoffs having someone like matthews above him is just so disrespectful lmao

Having matthews over draisaitl is flat out brutal lol only if u knew what draisaitl has accomplished last 3-5 seasons then u would know lmao

My opinion and I may be biased as a Devils fan, this year Hughes will pass Matthews and be the 4th best center in the league.

#21

Zib is close to Nico. Larkin is not.

A serious question (that is impossible to reliably answer)…if you switched Leon with any other center on this list, does he put up the same numbers elsewhere? (And does the other guy do the same?). Is he a 120-pt 1C? 80-pt guy?

That logic should also be applied to Thompson and Stutzle too then right?

I think even without McDavid, Leon is still a 100+ point player.