There is no upgrade here

Easy no for the Hawks.

This deal has them adding over $9m to their cap this season and retaining $2.2m for the next two seasons for a late 1st round pick and two 3rd round picks. On top of that they downgrade their D by going from Murphy to Myers, Timmins is a waiver wire caliber player with little or no value and the prospect is C level.

Brutal.

I don't see any reason why any of the other teams would do those deals.

Sharks aren’t giving up their last retention spot for a 5th and 7th.

No to Vancouver and Chicago

Hawks decline. The only piece in that deal that the Hawks would have any interest in is the 1st rounder. And that doesn't get Murphy w/ 3 years of retention. The rest of that is classic quantity over quality.

use out last retention spot for a couple late round picks lol aint happening kiddo

No need to trade a defenseman for another pick to add on to our thousands already.
Arizona says no.

If you can't fit a guy making $800k without retention then you have terrible asset management