Anaheim deal is fair, I'd say. Grant gets another chance to chase a ring, Anaheim gets a high-floor/low-ceiling type prospect.

Feel like you're giving up too much here. I like Soucy, sure, but he feels like a 2nd-and-a-prospect type value guy at best. Geekie has had a ton of shot luck to get his 4 goals in 15 GP, and I'd assume that at best he's getting a 3rd rounder in a trade. I think Seattle would jump on this trade and Toronto would be giving up a 1st for minor upgrades at best. Pass for the Leafs.

That’s all fair, and I don’t disagree the SEA trade is an overpay. Just think that’s probably what it will take to get reinforcements right now.

Yeah, fair deal from Anaheims side, we'd do it.

Honestly as Anaheim I'd just rather get a 4th round pick. But every Leafs deal has to be contract in/out neutral so there's that.

On that same token the Seattle deal doesn't work as is because of the extra contract going to the Leafs.

I’d do that Anaheim deal