Modifié 19 sept. 2021 à 14 h 30
Quoting: gretzkyghosts
Ledge_And_Dairy
Devil1122
sabres89
Please tell me why you want to make this trade at all!
Quinn has one more year of his ELC and based on your description, he is a lot more than a 2nd round better than Dahlin.
I think the Sabre ACGM would rather stick with the devil they know than the devil they do not.
IDK why you want to move away from Quinn, is there something about him that gives you reason to doubt how well he will play in the future.
Let's see how Dahlin does for a full year playing under the Granato system, as the team showed real progress last 20 games going 8-11-1 playing in the toughest division.
Players who were considered busts suddenly flourished and became Buffalo's top line (Asplund, Mittelstadt, Thompson).
Why I want to make the trade at all? I’m assuming you haven’t read the description or any of my previous posts, maybe do that first before commenting. If you are unable to understand after that I will explain again why I think it may be worth exploring for Vancouver.
Based on my description QH is worth a lot more than RD and a 2nd, interesting how you interpret things. The post you quoted was a response to a previous post that made inaccurate statements. If you go back and read previous posts you will see I have repeatedly said RD has a high ceiling and is good offensively.
Both project as #1 defence man. QH is currently the more dynamic and offensively gifted of the two, you don’t do a straight up trade for a downgrade unless there are significant contributing factors, such as age.
“I don’t know why you want to move on from QH”. Again do some reading…
If you think players that have been “busts” so far are all completely different players after 20 games I think your in for some disappointment. Not saying those players can’t turn it around (they are still young), not saying Granato won’t help, not saying RD won’t turn out to be a very good player, but lots of players play well for short stretches when changes are made.