He's the best of a bad defense, that's for sure. Although I think Muzzin is equally as important to the back end of this team.

Hyman is 100% MVP imo.

Defensively? Absolutely

It's gonna be a pain watching the team if Ceci is his partner.

Rielly played injured all season, it will be exciting to see him come back at 100%.

Hard to point to any one player as the sole mvp, Toronto has quite a few key players and everyone needs to perform their part.

Favorite Leaf aswell... You lose Matthews, we still got Tavares and the other way around. We lose any of our top 6 we have enough to keep our top 6 intact and capable of performing as they should

We lose reilly, we are cooked

Thank god we have him

I wonder if you have been watching any Leafs game this season. Reilly hasn't been very good...at at times not even good. His first eight games he might have been the Leaf worse Dman. Totally irresponsible defensively. Now he did smarten up and his play got better. This year he was only real positive play was on the PP...where I rate him very good. At even strength...slightly above average. Coaches tried to avoid putting him on the PK because it was better to go with other players.
Muzzin the Leafs best Dman this season by far IMO.

Reilly is one of the most underrated D men imo and also one of the leagues best defensmen. everybody thinks that he's bad because the leafs defense sucks, but he plays hard minutes and is actually more talented defensively than you would think. if he actually had someone to play with on the right side he'd be top 10 in the league. I would gladly have him on my team if he was somehow available for trade.

I wouldn't say equal