Columbus afford Bobrovsky. Plus he wouldn’t ever waive to go back to Columbus. He kinda left on bad terms.

I think you're also a little light on the Barkov deal.
Georgiev is worth a 5th, Strome had 1 good season with Panarin (he could put it together with Huby potentially)
Then it's essentially a three B+ prospects and a 2nd round pick.

Barkov is probably worth Howden + DeAngelo + Kakko + 1st

In other words, it would be dumb of Florida/NYR to make this deal

Georgiev is not worth a ****ing 5th.

3.04 SV%, lost his starting job to Shesterkin, Hasn't proven he's a starter, odd duck out in NY, not many teams looking for a goalie...

Markets slim for goalies as is, and given the upcoming UFA market for goalies, the market will become slimmer.

He had value when he was playing well. Just not consistent enough.

Yeah Georgiev is worth more than a 5th, id say around a 3rd or 2nd? And i could still be wrong?

BUT: To say Barkov is worth Kakko (just the second overall pick), DeAngelo (who just sparked in NY), Howden (who is a pretty decent prospect), and a middle of the road 1st is bad. It just is! I dont have a horse in this race, im just tryna help both of u guys.

Barkov for Strome, Georgiev, Howden, Kravitsov, and 2 firsts is more than sufficient on Floridas end, and more than acceptable for the Rangers to give up (not giving up a top 5 prospect in the league, etc...)

Lost his starting job to a superior goaltender?

Oh and just saw this as i posted: Goalies take longer to develop. So this arguement is also invalid unforunately.

If you saw what they got for Trocheck it wouldn't be the craziest idea to think it won't cost that much. Remember the Zibanejad Brassard trade? Melnyk didn't want to pay Zibbys signing bonus so he traded him for a 3C!!!!! Florida could get desperate and we could offer a slimmer package but it is still a good chance they under sell him.

I could maybe see Georgiev for a 3rd. I could be a bit harsh on him, I'm just not a huge fan.

And Kakko isn't a Top 5 prospect in the league. Neither is J. Hughes. Off the top of my head, both Quinn Hughes and Cale Makar were far and away the better players this season.

You have to consider Barkov is young, making 5.9 million, and consistently puts up 95 points.

Strome was bouncing around teams before settling in with Panarin, and looked lost when they split them up (maybe Panarin was injured, not 100% sure).
Lundkvist is unproven
Kravtsov hasn't touched NA ice, and didn't live up to the playoff hype in the following year in the K/MHL
The 1st will likely be pretty good, not franchise altering though
And Georgiev is inconsistent, and his value is probably at its lowest point, considering he is the backup/3rd goalie in NY and with the Wall signing it complicates things further.

You'd need to sell the farm for Barkov.

Bro when that zibby trade happened i was like damn thats terrible.
Even if they were nearly equal skillwise, zibby was younger and had so much more potential

I mean. Binner had a heck of a year. He's the same age as Georgiev, no?

Edit: Georgiev is 24, Binner is 26

I'd say a late 2nd to an early third. Rangers fans drastically overvalue his trade value.

Goaltenders rarely get what they are worth, and Georgiev's stats overall are enhanced by one hot streak. He's a career backup - a good one, but nonetheless a backup with jobshare ability.

Trocheck's value was also at its lowest point since he spent the majority of the season injured.
Trocheck is also a 2C.
I'd clump Barkov with centers like Bergeron/Tavares/Draisaitl.

I see the problem, you are basing young players value based on their seasons rather than their potential still:

Listen, as a bruins fan, im not gonna tell you zboril is still worth a 1st (being the 2015 first round pick), because he is beggining to lose value and become a bust.
However: Nils hasnt even played NHL action yet, Kakko had a hard Rookie Season (like Hughes), and again, like I said, Georgiev is a goalie and they take their time to develop. (think of Rask being traded for an old and washed up Andrew Raycroft because he wasnt developing fast enough for the leafs lol, goalies dont lose value that quick)

To your point that Barkov is a cheap contract, I did have that factored into my trade (which was a middle ground between yours and the other guys)

Good one lol

Calls Lundkvist and Kravtsov "B level prospects" and then counters with Howden

Fair points. If Florida was to rebuild though, they would need a solid franchise piece back.
Kakko could be that player. But C > Wingers (and my comparison would be Matthews who had 70 some odd points in his first season, or a better example would be A. Svechnikov who I think had somewhere around 45-50 points in his first season). Kakko was pretty inconsistent, but he has the potential to be very good.

Kakko, Lundkvist, 2020 1st. I still think there should be more for a guy like Barkov (guaranteed 90 points/season - for 2 or 3 more seasons (then it's a massive payday).
But those 3 pieces could be really nice for a rebuild

I mean... There are other pieces to that deal. Just not a big fan of Kravtsov. I could be persuaded on Lundkvist.

You basically said: "I don't want the best defensive prospect in Europe, or the KHL rookie of the year last season. Give me a borderline 4th line center"

It would be worth it though if they had behind the scenes show and Torts all season just chirped Bob.

"HOW MUCH YOU MAKE? 10 MILLION WONT EVEN GET 10 SAVES!!!"

or something like that

Kravtsov won RotY off a strong playoff performance, but then bounced around the K/MHL this year. His regular season last year was also super unimpressive.

And tbf, I know very little about Lundkvist, so I could be mistaken in calling him a B+ prospect.

Edit: it is the 17/18 playoffs I'm thinking of where he has 11 points in 16 games.
21 points in 50 games as a 19 year old in the K is pretty good.
His AHL tenure was pretty unimpressive though.

Lundkvist has the record for most points in SHL history for an under 20 and its not even close...He smashed the record.

30 points in 44 games is pretty impressive. Hopefully it translates in the NHL.

Late round steal too. (Kinda like Sandin)

Lol. Exactly. Columbus 100% doesn’t want Bob back.

No one wants with that contract lol.