SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

Nake_qc

Membre depuis
23 juin 2018
Équipe favorite
Canadiens de Montréal
Deuxième équipe favorite
Lightning de Tampa Bay
Messages dans les forums
148
Messages par jour
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GM24 juill. 2022 à 8 h 59
Sujet: Canadiens 22-23
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Campabee</b></div><div>Winnipeg is looking to get back to the playoffs, they need to get a replacement center in a PLD trade (Dvorak). They also need a guy of Anderson's ilk in their forward group, they have no one like that currently. And their bottom 6 could use a guy like Armia (who Jets fans know and love). I don't think that Chevy would accept this but I also don't think he would just hang up as you seem to be suggesting. A better deal for the Jets would be in the mold of the Tkachuk trade. Someone to replace PLD at center immediately Huberdeau for Tkachuk esk (Dvorak) + cap offset who may or may not extend but has high skill, with 1 year remaining on his contract Weegar esk (Drouin). Plus a top 10 protected 1st, we can skip the Schwindt and a 4th additions.</div></div>

You did not even reference the cap commitment that Winnipeg has to give in this situation. They're taking on contracts with term of middle-of-the-lineup players for an RFA top-6 center.

Here lets change the narrative.

Nashville will give Montreal Sissons, Granlund, and McDonagh for Kirby Dach if he won't sign (hypothetical).

A combined 14.6M (compared to the 13.3M in yours) for 3+ years for an RFA center that won't sign.

A bottom-6 guy, a center to replace Dach, and in this case, it's a veteran defenseman that gives the lineup an experienced mentor which they have no one like currently.

And yeah, I get it, comparisons are never the greatest because they're always different situations but Montreal doesn't even consider this whether they're contending or rebuilding.

Simply put, you can't trade a player with potential for a bunch of middle-of-the-lineup guys with lots of salary.
Forum: Armchair-GM22 juill. 2022 à 16 h 1
Sujet: OffSeason
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Nake_qc</b></div><div>Some deals are bad but there are a few at-least-we-can-discuss ones.
I had offered one a few days ago and from the comments you seemed to be in the minority,thinking it wasn't a good deal.
https://www.capfriendly.com/armchair-gm/team/3469617

Its not possible anymore and did count on the fact that we traded Peatry for a first.... But hey, I think I would of been a good starting point.
One thing to think of is what if his value drops throughout the year? What then for Wpg?

But as of right now, think it's better to way 1 or 2 years before talking about PLD.</div></div>

There's probably a better chance of his value going up with a good season. Yes, things can happen that lower value as well, but that's not thigh of a reason to accept a bad trade now.

You are right though, the most likely scenario is that we are all here again next summer talking about the same thing.
Forum: Armchair-GM18 juill. 2022 à 13 h 29
Sujet: Habs value chart for Dubois
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Lenny7</b></div><div>Excellent write up. I think the way I'm looking at it right now as non Jets/non Habs fan is this way:

Winnipeg needs to set a price and stick to it. I've heard the "He wants to go to Montreal!", "He's going to Montreal as a UFA in 2 years!", and "Winnipeg has no leverage!", but they've also got 2 years of control. If this is the price they've set, great, do it. If not, don't. Dubois is a 24 year old center that has absolutely no trade protection. If someone comes along and offers what you want, take it from them. Even with only 2 years, he still holds a ton of value to a playoff team, and they can just let him walk in 2 years. When you look at rental prices, the deadline this past year saw an absolute boatload going back for a number of rentals, so I'd be curious to see what 1.25 years of Dubois could even bring back.

All of that being said, he also completely quit on the Jackets before he was moved, so there's potential for him to do it again (in which case buyer friggin' beware! Imagine what happens in Montreal when he has a couple of bad weeks and the fans/media rip his soul out!).

I don't know...I guess it all depends on what they're actually looking for.

Cheers!</div></div>

I think if the Jets would be interested in a package deal, Hughes would of been able to figure something out by now (As you can see on here, in some cases, both fan bases can actually agree on certain package deals, which is extremely rare on CapFriendly lol). I think you're right, as in Cheveldayoff has set his price and is sticking to it. It's just that it's for one of MTLs untouchables.... so nothing is happening.
Forum: Armchair-GM12 juill. 2022 à 22 h 45
Sujet: Habs wSlafPLDprice ltir
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Nake_qc</b></div><div>All right. Thanks for the constructive feedback. Any tips?</div></div>

First off WHY do you want PLD? The guy is a sook, he cried his way out of Columbus because Torts hurt his feelings (which i can kind of get but still suck it up), now he is in Winnipeg and TELLS Management he has no intention of signing extension is going to test free agency, so he has no Loyalty, He is a talent and a good hockey player, but he is not a 100 pt per season guy (not yet anyway). Only reason he is WANTED is because he is French. He would crumble under the pressure in Montreal same as Drouin, another player who sooked and quit on his team to get traded and look how well that worked out for us.
I wouldnt trade For PLD, but if a trade was to be made it would have to be more Quality with upside to obtain him. Plus they made a move to get Dach to be their future #2 center.

As for the Allen Deal, thats probably doable.

Petry I dont think gets a first now, and to be honest I prefer move him for young prospects, if it is Dallas, someone like Mavrik Bourque, or Wyatt Johnston, or Buffalo for Olivier Nadeau, and a 2nd rdpick