If PIT finishes with a top 10 pick, it will be the first time in 12 years they are drafting in the top 10. They'll probably need another equally high upside roster player coming back if they trade that pick. So while that is a valuable package in terms of quantity, they desperately need more of a quality return on the upside.

What about:

Winnipeg's 2024 1st
Calgary's (Florida's) 2025 1st
Pittsburgh's 2025 2nd
Barron
Farrell

for 10th overall

i think armia has value now, elite defensive forward. cap hit is meh, but he is found gold if you are down a man.

pending ufa next year. he goes for a mid round pick or another warm body coming back.

Dallas trade seems highly unlikely.

I agree, but I moved him because I don't see a spot for him on the team. Missing out on a mid round pick isn't a deal breaker for a team that has stockpiled picks since I was in grade 11 (I am 22)

Given the lack of depth in Pittsburgh's prospect pool, the Penguins might be effectively forced into taking that offer, but jfkst1's point is well taken: Pitt might want an actual NHL player at the top of that offer. Maybe replace Barron with one of your surplus existing NHL lefties?

Dallas has Heiskanen and Harley on the left plus one more season of both Lindell and Suter. I don't think that the Stars will invest those kind of assets in two seasons of Matheson. Bourque in particular seems like too much.

I don't see Dvorak getting a second in the off-season. That's the return from an injury-stricken team desperate for help at the trade deadline.