Quoting: dgibb10
I’d rather have kuemper who was dominant as a workhorse on a bad Arizona team than a Ullmark who’s never handled a true starters workload behind a defensively sound system in Boston and has disastrous playoff results
But like I said, if it came down to it I’d offer 1st+ conditional 3rd for Ullmark at 5 mill vs 1st+prospect+conditional 3rd for kuemper at 3.4 mill
Also just curious did you intentionally name a bunch of “comps” that have no age comparison while ignoring other comps of veteran goalie rentals like fluery, lehner to Vegas, bishop, etc to try and raise what the perceived value was?
Kuemper's best year in Arizona statistically came when he played in 29 games. He only had one season in Arizona where he played more than 30 games, which was 57 appearances in 2018-2019, so he was really only a "workhorse" for one season. In his 10 year career, he has only made more than 30 appearances three times.
- Lehner to Vegas trade got a second round pick and two prospects - I don't think its a good comp because of Lehner's off-ice baggage, he was playing some of his worst hockey in Chicago, and fell out of favor with the GM and was not in the team's future plans. Source: https://theathletic.com/1631997/2020/02/24/blackhawks-trade-goaltender-robin-lehner-to-golden-knights/.
Some excerpts: But Lehner left quietly, muddling through the worst stretch of his season and being shipped off to Las Vegas ahead of Monday’s trade deadline. The Blackhawks are getting a second-round pick, goaltender Malcolm Subban and defenseman prospect Slava Demin, per Sportsnet’s Chris Johnston. Lehner, a Vezina finalist a year ago with the New York Islanders, was a surprise free-agent signing in July, coming to Chicago on a one-year, $5-million contract. His openness about his mental health and alcoholism during his time in Buffalo made him a symbol of strength and hope for many, but apparently made him too big of a risk for most general managers around the league. In the meantime, Crawford — who significantly outplayed Lehner over the past month, posting a .939 save percentage compared to Lehner’s .888 — remains the Blackhawks’ goalie of the present and possibly the future.
- Fleury was 6 years older than Ullmark currently is so less market for a 36 year old than a player still in his prime.
- Which Bishop trade are you referring to? The 2017 trade to LA Kings where he had a full NMC?