Why is Minny giving up so much more value here????

Don't need a V2 of Max Domi on the Canes unless he's willing to be a fourth line center

How is it so much more value?

Nylander >>>>> Body
Robertson>>>>>Dewar
Holmberg>>Maroon

Yurov and the difference between Faber and Lili makeup all the value going to Minnesota

Hahahaha what????

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Nylander ain't that much better than Boldy. Christ, the massive overrating of Nylander by Leafs fans is getting old.

I guarantee you Minnesota doesn’t trade Boldy for Nylander straight up. Cry all you want, Boldy has the edge in both age, term and control. Not too mention full potential.

Dewar is a speedy bottom six defensive minded PK wizard who was top 3 in SHG across the league last year, and oh yeah, just scored a hat trick Friday night. I assure you Robertson doesn’t carry that much more value than him. If any at all.

Holmberg is an Ahl'er at age 24, had 13 points in 37 games last year. But went scoreless in 7 games this year. But somehow carries better value than a 3-time Stanley Cup champion who currently has 11 points in SIXTEEN less games than it took Holmberg at age 35?

Mmmmmm'kay... whatever you say, you're wrong, but okay.

Yurov is a top A-level prospect who's worth at minimum of a 1st. While Faber currently carries around the same value as Luke Hughes.

The value here isn't close, and HEAVILY favors Toronto. Don't be a 🤡.

I laughed just as much seeing that😂

The Liljegren overvalue got me more than the Willy one did honestly

Hey, I'll grant and give Leafs fans Lily is a 2nd pairing caliber defenseman all day long. There IS value there.

The problem is that Faber is literally a 1st pairing caliber defenseman as a rookie at 22 already and only going to get better. There's a reason that even Devil's fans can agree his value is on par with Hughes right now.

And we already know that NJ doesn't trade Luke Hughes straight up for Nylander either. The same literally applies to Minnesota with Faber. And that's literally the reason why it's such an overpay. That's two players in this trade that Minnesota wouldn't trade for Nylander in an even 1v1 swap. Let alone both.

They want to trade us Nylander? Cool, he's a guy we can't afford to resign, so he's strictly a rental. Therefore he gets rental prices. I'll give them Yurov, Kumpulainen, and a 2025 1st (top ten protected).

And NO I'm NOT giving Toronto a current top 5 pick/potential top ten pick for a rental Nylander. The 2024 1st isn't available. Just like Boldy. Just like Faber.