Petey gets way more than 9.5 and thats not even close.

Petey's contract will probably be 1.5-2 million more per season.

As well, I understand some people in montreal think Guhle is a top calibre Dman, but everyone outside of Quebec recognize he is a fringe top 4 prospect right now. replace him with reinbacher and canucks consider this more heavily.

also, protection on the pick? no chance

Yes top5 protection... not top 10.
Guhle is a stud and solid Top4... getting more and more offensive upside

Guhle is project and could easily top out at 3rd pair calibre. dach is a middle 6 centre or 2nd line winger. and then adding top 5 protection to the pick?

very limited upside for vancouver here and huge risk. pettersson is the most valuable trade chip vancouver has ever had. it will cost more than this

Not even close on the trade or the contract

One of -- Slafkovsky, Dach, Caufield, Suzuki
One of -- Reinbacher, Guhle
One of -- Beck, Farrell, Newhook, Hutson
One of -- 2024 1st, 2025 1st

...is probably the price just to get in the door

(Start at Eichel comp...and look up)

This site is endlessly funny to me. People post a thread for EP from Columbus and it's Jirichek Johnston and a 1st and people say it's enough, then you come to a Habs post and it's Slaf, Reinbacher, Hutson and a top 5 pick to get EP. The bias is real

its probbaly because jiricek johnson and a 1st is a better package than slaf reinbacher hutson and a first? lol

as a habs fan I agree on the guhle take fringe top 4 def earned his role in the top 6 but is fringe top 4. then again he basically had the same comparisons to sanderson just in a smaller sample and the dude got like 8.2 for 8yrs so if hes considered elite is guhle same?
mind u sanderson was on a ottawa senators whos d is strong in the top 4
id be more confortable sending
one of Beck Mesar
one of farrell Hieneman
1rst 24
1rst 25
1rst 25
one of Gally Anderson

Untouchables
-rienbacker -hutson -dach -suzuki -caufield -guhle -monty -newhook -slafkovsky -roy
Possible nice peices
-Davidson -Kidney -Barron -Harris -engstrom -rhp -ylonen -simoneau

send counter offer be aware mailloux no one probably wants but is really really solid prospect and is RH

You stole what I was about to say

If Josh Anderson can return Simon Nemec and a 1st.

Maybe I should be saying, "2.5 Josh Andersons"

Counter offer is Montreal will not acquire pettersson. easy peasy

The Habs package is about double the Columbus package

I think Guhle looks very legit

At least Matthews+ for Anderson

"He's big"
- A lot of Habs fans

If they ask for Sam Montembeault, I'd walk.

far from a guaruntee. huge downside risk

They don't call them, Wrad Wreliving or Wom Witzgerald

lol

Eh the truth makes the simple minded laugh sometimes

classic delusional habs fans, never change fellas

Maybe (probably true for almost any 21-yr old in NHL).

But I have been impressed with him.

all ik is mtls goaltending situation and in there system is so bad there is no one for the future so for now a 26yr old who has some flashes needs to work

Which is better package?

A. CBJ: Jiricek, Johnson, 1st
B. MTL: Slafkovsky, Reinbacher, Hutson, 1st

I'm stumped. 4 good pieces is better than 3...but man, Jiricek and Johnston both look like they may be elite guys...so I'm leaning CBJ.

Allen in short-run
Add Dobes, Primeau for medium-term
Fowler is the future

Monty should be expendable imo