Quoting: HockeyManiac95
The Avs tried that same merry-go-round technique last year with 2C and it didn't go well.
Totally agree with you on getting a new D, just thought I'd see how this idea flies. But I do have a question for you. Assuming that if we did float 3-4 guys in the 3RW spot, would u be OK if we floated Hunt/JJ/MacDermid/Malinski/and maybe Middleton thru 6D?
You're not wrong when you say they tried the same merry go round technique last year with 2C, the Avs had just shed all their cup winning depth and went into last season under-staffed though.
It is an entirely different situation with the depth pieces they've added for this season so I feel like that is not a direct comparable, even with injuries in the forward group for this upcoming season they'll have way better depth available to shuffle around as needed this year, especially when Kovalenko is available.
The main issue I have is that you need 6 quality D and still depth beyond that so while I am a fan of both Hunt and JJ, they aren't good enough at shut down D or fast enough to be able to skate corner to corner in their own end to compensate them being paired with Girard. If we still had EJ I wouldn't feel this way because EJ was smart enough to know when to truck someone into the boards and when he shouldn't so he could offer support to Girard. This brings up probably my biggest gripe with Girard himself is that he requires a partner who is fast enough to skate corner to corner throwing his body around. EJs foot speed has really taken a hit the past couple years and he still did wonderful last season but it was easy to tell the writing was on the wall for this season.
Trading Girard and using the 7+ mill available to sign someone like Statsny/Kessel while still being able to pursue a viable 5-6 D replacement in the 2-3 mill range is a path i'd be willing to take this summer. You don't need to replace G's offensive output directly but you need someone competent at shut down D that can PK to take minutes away from Makar, And that could be 2 D players replacing Girard and still adding 1 of Statnsy/other to the bottom 6 F group.
I don't think Middleton will see much NHL ice unless we *knock on wood* get riddled with injuries again this season, Malinski I have seen enough of to know he has a chance to turn some heads at the NHL level but he likely still needs another 1-2 years to fully develop and i'm not a fan of rushing prospects. Lyubushkin from Sabres is the type of player I have in mind to come in the 5-6 spot, he would pair a lot better with either Hunt or JJ and could still add a guy like caleb jones or ethan bear to have the appropriate depth so Makar can drop to 20-22 mins a game and not 25+ all season.