Matthews is better than Peterson, Crosby for sure and IMO better than Drasaitl and Mack but that's just opinion... he should 100% be there
Josi def. best LD
Karlsson should be there, over Andersson
Rantanen's being disrespected and Tkachuk/Kucherov's overrated
i hate the leafs just as much as anyone, but not having Matthews down the middle is a crime
edit* Josi / karlsson
Quoting: Juiceman
Andersson top 5 is a bit suspect. Also would love to call Pettersson a top 5 C, but I don’t think everybody would agree
Quoting: mv21227
Matthews at C
Marchand at LW
Josi at LD (I’d bump Slavin or Dahlin off for him)
Hamilton and Karlsson/Pietrangelo/Pesce at RD
Hellebuyck at G
Quoting: mokumboi
Brady and Connor are better than Keller. And you forgot Josi.
Edit: Oh hell, and Matthews. I just kinda assumed he was there even when he wasn't.
Def forgot matthews, i didnt include karlsson bc his defensive game isn't very good, josi i forgot too but hughes could make the case. keller has a bit of bias but he is undoubtably top 5 imo. hellebuyck is definitely elite and is no 6 for me, oettinger is a bit streaky but their very close