🤣🤣🤣🤣... This is historically bad for WPJ

This is better than they will get.

Just like all the Monahan for 1st trades or Edmunson for a 1+b tier prospect trades?

Who knows. Monahan was injured. It's a moot point.

Eddy wil get a Chiarot return next TDL. Guaranteed.

Monohan wouldn't have gotten a 2nd this past TDL

Edmunson will not be getting what Chiarot return unless there is literally nobody else on the market

You forgot Petry.

My bad

Oh please. Mony had 17pts in 24gp with over 52% FOW. Please, pull up your pants, your homer is showing.

Eddy is a great Defensive Dman. Again, I would agree or debate rational responses. But your take is not a hockey take. Its a tunnel vision anit-Hab take.

Take care.

Matheson has been a stud. A cheaper & younger Petry. A win. But, could have gotten a 1st as well.

Seriously people. Watch more hockey.

Ok but Matheson won't return a 1st either. If Montreal could've gotten a 1st for Petry they would have taken it. 1st rd pick > 30yr old dman. Petry and Matheson practically having identical seasons. Plus Petry has one less year on his contract.

omg, are you people just blind or just hate? I dont get it.

Matheson is 6 years younger. $1.4m cheaper. Having a better offensive season ppg. And has a higher +/- on a losing team.

How are you willfully blind to facts?

My bad... an average 3rd line centre playing with 1 of Slaf, Caufield or Suzuki whom is very bang average at face-offs isn't worth a 1st

Edmunson is a defensive liability with little offensive upside... there's a reason why according to only MTL outlets have reported teams wanting him (I'll give a hint... It's because he isn't very good)

Ok dude. Enjoy.

I will

Players values don't go up when they play in MTL

Must be tough having so much disdain it makes you irrational.

The fact that you brought up +/- just proves you have no idea about hockey. IT'S A USELESS STAT!!!!!!!!!

Generally, unless your a minute eater on a last place team with a MINUS SIXTY TWO GOAL DIFFERENTIAL.

Man, I cant anymore. You guys enjoy. I've had enough futility for one day. Holy jebus.

Why, because I don't want your trash players. for a premium?

Who are you to call NHL players trash?

In perspective to Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, Nylander, Rielly, Brodie, Tavares, McCabe, Sammy... you're players aren't anywhere near as good

Aside from all your overpaid players that stop you from icing a deep enough roster to actual win or advance into the playoffs, you are right. Great players, the Leafs big 4 forwards. Albeit on a mismanaged roster that hasn't had goaltending since Toskala. Comparing these two roster is asinine. A supposed contender and a rebuilding team. Just silly irrational.

Regardless, this is beside the point. Which I see is a trend with you. A word Im forced to use often, irrational. Regardless, remember that playoffs? 1-3? ...shhhh

Here is your logic: Anything that somewhat disagrees with what I'm saying and proves it is not related to the topic bc I would lose otherwise...On this Leafs roster, Monahan plays 4C (maybe, Kampf provides more value than Monahan IMO but I'm not the Leafs Head Coach), Edmunson doesn't get into the lineup and Josh Anderson is 3rd/4rth line LW. Those aren't worth 1st round picks

Thanks for your, irrational opinion! Appreciated as always.

He's spitting anderson is overpaid and mid, monahan can't stay healthy, and edmundson gets caved in every time he steps foot on the ice