not sure why Panthers would want to Sell. Its been reported they plan on continuing to push for the playoffs
Their 1st round pick is in montreals hand, why would they want to actively make themselves worse?

Panthers gave up essentially the same thing for Reinhart now you add gudas. They decline

Reinhart was my favorite sabre when he was here and I'd love to have him back but no chance florida trades him.

Agreed. This looks like an off-season move more than a deadline trade.

I'm assuming Reinhart was moved because he didn't want to be in Buffalo, he never seemed like he enjoyed being here

I could see the panthers moving Reinhart during the offseason, 1 year left, they dont have any cap space to extend him so they might be best to try to re-coop some of the assets they have spent over the last few seasons taking their shot at the cup.

What would Hinostroza 50% retained cost?

Idk, a 4th?

What about a 2024 5th?

Sure