short a first and a second in the horvat trade

Dumba's not that good. I don't see Van adding a 1st and 2nd.

That Boston trade is bad for Vancouver

I mean a Canucks fan proposed this, not a fan of another team

Still a terrible trade for Vancouver

Canucks easily decline both trades

i see the wild adding that with dumba

Still really bad for the canucks - coming from a bruins fan.


That’s a bit much.

with*

Right. That’s a bit much.

if horvat gets resigned its not that bad, dumba isnt special

Right, but horvat isn’t re-signed, and he isn’t special either. Better than dumba, but a 1st and a 2nd more for a rental is bonkers.

vancouver is trying to resign him for sure. top 6 , two way center good on draws that can score 25-30 goal is pretty good id say, also those picks are going to be late so yea, its not that much.

horvat had more goals than dumba had points. so yea id say hes better and by far

Find a comparable. You’re asking for something unprecedented to happen. Minnesota doesn’t care if vancouver is trying to re-sign him or not.



….he’s a defensemen….

And he’s been missing games for the past 5 years dealing with injuries. If you want horvat you’ll need to add those picks

His value isn’t what you think it is. It’s simple as that, dumba is a Ok dmen dealing with health issues, Horvat is possibly a first line Center on that team so yea there’s a price to pay to land him, he’s a good reliable top 6 player. Anyways I’m pretty sure Vancouver does everything they can to resign him

Also I don’t need to find a comparable , horvat is obviously the better player and he’s not getting moved unless they get good picks attached to that meh dmen

Garland is a better player, and younger so I don't see why we would even consider this. That Horvat trade is also pretty bad for us.

Wild aren't interested in rentals. So they won't be trading dumba to add another rental they won't keep

The quote function is your friend.

Any time you’re proposing something that is unprecedented in the nhl, chances are you’re being crazy.

I don’t want horvat. This isn’t my ACGM and I don’t manage an nhl team. Perhaps in whatever alternate universe you’re in horvat gets dumba, a first, and a second. That’s not a real world thing though.

You thought dumba was fair value for horvat.. but im the one living in a different universe, good one

No I didn’t. I said the exact opposite. Read better

mbd

What?