Pass

What's the breaking point for you?

Yeah I don't hate this from either side. Seems tough to part ways with both players going the other way but when you look at the return, it makes sense in a way for both sides.

Sharongovich will be sneaky good, was offered in alot of MT deals. I think they need to keep some of their good depth and Nylander is got a yr left no?. Nylander I great but seems lazy abd disappears in the playoffs, what's up with that. If Severson is gonna bolt, I'm OK with him to Tor, but I prefer him to stay, I'm in the minority though our fanbasecis split on him. Our RHD should be set, in fact I think we are done building the D

Nylander is always getting the wrath of the media for "Gutless " playing. I think the fans appreciate him more.
I've always liked his playing style.

Willy has actually put up some decent playoff numbers last couple of seasons, but he does have moments where he seems hesitant to take a hit to make a play. Then other times he’s throwing a hit and producing turnovers.

All in all I think this is a good hockey trade and does fill needs for both teams.

Including Sharangovich here makes it way too lopsided in the Leafs favour.
Wouldn't want to include Shango in any deal for two years of Nylander, think that'd be a big mistake.

If the Leafs for some reason feel like moving Nylander is the right idea (I don't but let's just go with it), using Severson as a base seems pretty reasonable, with the Devils adding secondary pieces to meet fair value.
I think Severson + a 2nd + Foote pretty much meets fair value for Nylander.
Not sure the Devils can take Holl back here however, they don't have as much cap space rn as they usually do.

Sharangovich for 5 years > Nylander for 2 years

Agree ^