Quoting: TheAlien
Lol of course you're bringing up last year's plus/minus (which is a garbage stat anyways). O zone starts is also a terrible stat because it doesn't account for on the fly starts which makes up the majority of starts. So the difference between 68% and 39% isn't as big as you're trying to insinuate it is. He was absolutely horrible defensively last year. But that's not the case anymore he's completely fixed his defensive issues with scrubs as d partners and is even killing penalties under Boudreau now.
A. yes +/- is a garbage stat. but it doesn't hid the fact when guys are bleeding goals on the ice and losing while they are out there. There is no hiding that about it. Considering it's the defenseman who are to prevent things like that from happening....
B. No Zone starts are not a bad stat. It's nice of you to try to go with that, but you can directly correlate that state with points all across the league for the obvious point of it shows where guys are deployed on the ice and how and it really does show their role on a team.
Players who are hidden have high offensive zone starts. You can directly correlate that stat with say, Bergeron aging and losing his legs. How he went from a top shut down center to a guy who primarily gets O zone starts because they can't run him up and down the ice anymore. Not knocking his production in the Ozone one bit, but it's clear the obvious attempt to save his legs.
I know it's hard for you to admit that guys getting O zone starts help in their point production but it's very true. Much like it's true that Quinn being put in every hard start in his own D zone would drastically effect his play and numbers and would expose him.
Lets not pretend it doesn't matter while you are over here trying to knock a guy who gets primary defensive zone deployment for not "getting points" to the same rate while claiming that is what makes someone a better defenseman. That's just bs and anyone with hockey sense knows that. Fact is Marino plays a role Quinn can not because he's a very good Defenseman every bit as good as Quinn some my argue better due to his ability to play his own zone. Something Quinn is not particularly good at.