I wouldn’t say our goaltending has been good. I would say it’s been mediocre. Hathaway just need to stop taking bad penalties. Can you put the powerplay as awful

I’m so proud of Martin fer. Dude has been bailing out Carlson all season long

I'm giving them the benefit of having some horrid play in front of them recently. Giving up 12 shots in the first 10 minutes of the San Jose game last night kind of epitomizes the struggles as of recent. Goaltending just keeps getting the short end of the stick with these games.

I'm not sure what penalties Hath takes (but I'm not really paying attention so I'm not really sure), but I think his play has been pretty good this year, I especially liked his stint on the 1nd line, and I think he has done enough to be a B Grade.

Mr Clean can get his own Category.

Pretty cool idea. Thanks for this

I would move Carlson and Sheary to C and put Schultz in F

Why has Carlson been so awful this year? I assume it’s a defensive issue and not an offensive issue?

At some point we have to question if Forsythe has some blackmail over Ted or GMBM because there's literally no reason this dude should still be employed.

I’ve been impressed with Sheary this year. I think the sorting for B was wrong since he should be much closer to C than he his, but I think he’s been good enough for now to squeak into a B. I

might be a bit too harsh on Carlson, but D or F is where I think he belongs. His offense feels like it’s lacking a bit from prior years, but it’s mostly due to turning the puck over quite a lot in bad spots, and ending up out of position too often for my liking.

I debated having Schultz between D and F but I think he’s gotten a bit too much hate. He’s been the unfortunate one on the D to not have a constant linemate, being shuffled around with Irwin, TVR, Cholo, freaking Kempny at one point. I don’t blame him for looking a bit worse, but I did like him on the 1PP during Carlson’s absence, so I’m giving him the benefit of the doubt for now. Could change quickly though.

From my point of view, he has a lot of bad turnovers and has a decent amount of moments where I find myself cringing at his play. Seems worse when I watch him in person.

He must know where the bodies are hidden.

Thanks, but not my idea. Got it from @A_k and his Blues report cards

I need to add guys that need to be sent to the sun to the Blues one *sideeyes Marco Scandella*

My one problem with Schultz and Carlson being there is that Schultz is not nearly as good as Carlson, Carlson has always been bad defensively and he is still putting up good numbers this year that’s why I would put him in C