Flames still decline

you=🤡, marner is a mile better than tkachuk

Lol ok bud, if you have no idea what you are talking about I suggest not talking at all

Is that the only stat that shows Tkachuk is better? Marner would add 25 goals from himself and another 25 goals extra added to the players on his line. I would rather keep Marner.

Lol ok bud, if you have no idea what you are talking about I suggest not talking at all

you=🤡, marner is a mile better than tkachuk

You do realize Marner is a passer hence why his CF/60 is lower, yet he still controlled the xGF/60 and xGA/60. There’s also a reason why Tkachuk was only able to score over at a ppg only twicein his career. It’s because he plays second line competition. His EV toi is significantly lower than Marner and Tkachuk doesn’t even kill penalties.

In this deal Toronto overpaid and trying to bring up advanced stats with little to no context doesn’t help you’re case as it was easy to debunk.

That is 5 different stats there and they are some of the best for showing a players overall game.

How can Marner add 25 goals for himself if hes literally only scored 25+ once in his career? That doesnt even make sense. The only thing Marner is much better than Tkachuk at is passing the puck to a superstar goal scorer. Thachuk doesnt even get that option. Tkachuk however is as good or better defensively, way more physical, one of the best in the league in penalties drawn, and an actual team leader. Oh not to mention he is not overpaid

Better defensively then Marner, only Brad Marchand is a better 2 way forward then Marner. By the sounds of it Thachuk doesn't even play the pk.

That is 5 different stats there and they are some of the best for showing a players overall game.

How can Marner add 25 goals for himself if hes literally only scored 25+ once in his career? That doesnt even make sense. The only thing Marner is much better than Tkachuk at is passing the puck to a superstar goal scorer. Thachuk doesnt even get that option. Tkachuk however is as good or better defensively, way more physical, one of the best in the league in penalties drawn, and an actual team leader. Oh not to mention he is not overpaid[/quote

If Tkachuk is better defensively, they why didn't you show those stats. Marner can actually pass the puck to anyone, he doesn't need a star (career year for Kadri). The two players are not really comparable, they play a different game, but Marner is better then Tkachuk in many ways. I would love to have Tkachuk, but not at the cost of Marner.

If Tkachuk is better defensively, they why didn't you show those stats. Marner can actually pass the puck to anyone, he doesn't need a star (career year for Kadri). The two players are not really comparable, they play a different game, but Marner is better then Tkachuk in many ways. I would love to have Tkachuk, but not at the cost of Marner.

Just adding more stats to the discussion:

Or is Mitch Marner the best winger in Canada? #LeafsForever pic.twitter.com/oxrl3Ocdr1

— JFresh (@JFreshHockey) May 24, 2021

Matthew Tkachuk reportedly might want out of Calgary. Who do you think would be a good fit for him? #cofred pic.twitter.com/r1msSFP9ht

— JFresh (@JFreshHockey) June 22, 2021

Alright as an outside opinion, contracts considered would you rather have Matthew Tkachuk or Mitch Marner on your team (assume Tkachuk extends with good term since thinking otherwise defeats the purpose)

Is that the only stat that shows Tkachuk is better? Marner would add 25 goals from himself and another 25 goals extra added to the players on his line. I would rather keep Marner.

Lol ok bud, if you have no idea what you are talking about I suggest not talking at all

can you read the chart? more goals get scored and less go in his own net when hes on the ice, the only thing tkachuk has is his corsi. Corsi means nothing if you dont finish your chances.

Marner because hes a way better player, normally you have to pay for really good players

Alright as an outside opinion, contracts considered would you rather have Matthew Tkachuk or Mitch Marner on your team (assume Tkachuk extends with good term since thinking otherwise defeats the purpose)

It's hard to consider with contracts since Tkachuk only has 1 year left. If he extends with good term what's the AAV?

Well that was my point, Tkachuk would have to extend with term of the conversation is irrelevant. If I had to guess an AAV for him I would say 8.5-9M since Calgary probably files for arbitration to void the QO